Donna,
Your green thumb is showing , from cutting to fruit in the first season.
I've found that Atreano is best tasting for me when it turns more yellowish and develops lots of skin cracks.
More than any other variety that I've tried , Atreano needs to be very very ripe to show its best flavor.
Last year I was happiest with the taste when I waited until it was what I thought was dead ripe and then waited another week before picking it !