I like Brooklyn White. Took ours about five years before it stopped producing tuff skins. Has produced honey sweet brebas here, even when we could only register 565 cooling degree days. It also puts out a good main crop, even after being hit with frost.
We got our start of Brooklyn White from Bass, at Trees of Joy. Bass found this one growing in Brooklyn, NY., winter uncovered. Made my self sick last fall for eating them all day for a week.
Next would be LaRadek's English Brown Turkey. Big crop of brebas. It has produced big breba crops with out being covered, even with winter lows of 10 to 15 below Fahrenheit. Sweet but does not have as much flavor as Brooklyn White. But it makes up for that with volume. Although, I tried to get new customers to try Desert King, LaRadeks EBT is the one most asked for.
Third, for me, would be Desert King. Not as cold hardy as the two above. But, it's being grown as far north as Michigan in a zone 5b, covered. It's also being grown out side in Canada. Simply can't be beat for those who like honey tasting figs. In a pot inside, It gives us big great tasting figs as early as July. Well worth the effort of covering for the winter. If you plant them at a 45 degree angle, you should be able to bend them to the ground come fall. We then cover with about 10 40 lb. bags of potting soil. Which can be had in the fall for pennies on the dollar, or free. Should only take 30 minutes to an hour to cover each year.
We are testing the above here in Connecticut, zone 5b/6a, along with others. But, have not been testing them long enough to recommend.
Valliery is starting to look very promising, for a heavy producing breba. But, have not been able to tell much how cold it's breba can take.
Sodus Black, is producing breba without being covered in up state New York. Has been very hard to propagate.
I can provide a list of both main crop and breba crop figs we have been testing here in Connecticut for the last ten years or so.
Can send to any one who wants it.
Send a direct email request to: <robertcharper@gmail.com>
Bob