Aaron,
The reason for my question comes from the great and and positive impact caused by your black fig, showing that deep red full pulp and a cracked ostiole... These signs could be an indicator of the presence of nearby Caprifigs and their fig wasps which some time at early Summer (end of June) could have pollinated your figs (?).
Over and above this, I believe not to be wrong, admitting that Caprifigs may still exist in your area.
You should not be worried having Caprifigs as neighbors.. In your place, I would be extremely HAPPY !!
The wasp which pollinates figs (Blastophaga psenes) is a very minute insect (2.5 mm) which lives inside the Caprifig, totally inoffensive, and thanks to it we enjoy now many hundreds of excellent and some fabulous varieties of figs .
Let me suggest you check this link, with many related sub-links and read extremely use full information on the sex of the fig flowers, Caprifigs, pollination, etc..
http://waynesword.palomar.edu/pljune99.htm#fighybrid
cheers
Francisco