I'll be honest and say I have never tasted a Celeste fig until I tasted mine. But from peoples descriptions of "so sugary sweet", mine is not, unless someone thinks peaches taste sugary sweet.
Yeah, I think it's a good thing, but I'm rarely that lucky to just buy something cool and not know it. It is a keeper for sure. My wife said "and this one (Celeste) isn't supposed to be as tasty as these" (pointing at other figs from cuttings, VdB, Smith, etc). We are both very happy with it's taste.
I like the name Texas Peach. There are more figs yet to ripen, I hope it stays consistent.
Blueboy and WillsC, glad to hear someone else has had similar experience so I'm not "crazy". I think the leaves on yours is similar, especially the new ones.