Eli, the leaves are as you described. In its second year the Black Brogiotto that I have has failed to ripen any fruit for me. I'm starting to think that mine might need the fig wasp. Perhaps it was stressed being root bound. I just moved the tree to my fig forest, perhaps it will do better as it outgrew the pot too fast.
My Black Brogiotto grew as a single trunk while the Black Madeira is very slow and trying to grow like a bush with many branches. These are two different trees for sure.
Although they were rooted at the same time, the Black Madeira managed to ripen about half a dozen top tasting figs for me last summer after it was killed to the ground. Now that it is all new growth, it is a very promising tree. I wrapped it up this winter in order to avoid freeze damage and allow the branches to build some mass. We'll see...