phil, if you use fines only, and stick to the 5-1-1 ratio, you will have a very fast draining mix.
your mix won't drain properly because you used 3 parts compost. you may end up with perched water.
next time, try sticking to the proper ratio and compare for yourself.
using regular mulch won't cure this. the reason for screening to get fines is to regulate particle size. this is not hard to do. just buy a piece of
1/2'' hardware mesh and screen it.
if you don't wanna do that, pet stores and amazon have fines under the name of reptibark.
or, orchard supply stores have a very nice grade of fines
in my opinion, properly made 5-1-1 is the perfect potting medium for any plant. the only thing i ever vary is lime, acid loving plants like the mix as is, but figs do need lime as 5-1-1 is acidic.