I've had a few fig trees here in Tucson now for 3 years.
I have a Panache planted in ground, and like your experience, mine is the most vigorous and productive tree I have.
I have VdB in ground that is also very vigorous and productive. It grows wider and shorter than Panache.
I have a Black Madeira in a sip and it is a productive tree for it's size but grows very slow.
I have a couple RdB in containers, they grow tall but sparse and aren't big producers.
I have a Vista in a container and it seems to match my VdB in all aspects.
I have a Hardy Chicago in container that is doing very well, productive but the fruit are small.
Not a dark fig, but I have an Adriatic JH planted in ground that is struggling, I may replace it.
Overall, from my very limited experience, I would recommend VdB/Vista. The fruit is fantastic and
my tree does really well with the local climate. My only negative observation is that it is always a
thirsty tree and seems to need extra water.
I also have had the best luck with transplanting into the ground in the fall, generally late
Oct/ early Nov.