It isn't a dead horse, just a bit of a mystery, so far. Sue, I doubt that age is the answer, but can't prove that. I wouldn't have expected someone to have grown a fig tree for years, or decades, in hopes that one day it would ripen sooner. My Black Madeira is 15+ years in the ground. Hopefully we will get a better handle on those trees this season - in their "native" Point Loma. It is possible that it is a mutation or different strain of Black Madeira which is characterized by earlier ripening. Just don't know, at this point. The one a Davis, which has been there quite a while, while ripening earlier than mine, also enjoys a much warmer fig climate, and was ripening when we were there, which was pretty much the end of the season, there (ending earlier because of the warmer climate).