Geoff,
Welcome to the forum community.
Your fig resembles the Brunswick/Madonna variety, which has an Amber to Pink interior and Tan to brown exterior.
The Stella/Cordi cultivar has a Red interior and Green exterior... note attached Stella pictures, the leaves do look similar. The Stella fig pictures are from a vendor's web page.
You could try pinching the branches or thinning the figlets to reduce production and concentrate the plants energy into ripening the "limited" crop of figs. There are many other cultivars that will produce earlier and are cold hardy enough for in ground planting in your zone (improved Celeste, Celeste, Hardy Chicago Sals etc). Good Luck.
.