Ah, it's just that the whole fig tasting scene is waaaaay different from the tea(especially puerh) and wine drinking scene when it comes to describing why something is better or not. There tends to be only a few descriptors, and it rarely tends to be helpful as far deciding which figs are truly desired. I have very little idea of what "rich" actually means, and I have every intention of inviting myself over to satellitehead's community garden and get a broader sense of what figs offer.
Right now, I have only a smidge concept of why anything's better than another. Black Madeira, for instance offers texture, sweetness, and aftertaste. Ronde de Bordeaux offers sweetness and a spicy, thin skin, or something like that. I have no real idea of why Ischia Black or Maltese Falcon should be considered great, except the former is fruity? Barnisotte and Col de Dame has strong berry taste, but more to it than that, for different reasons, and I'd love to try out Zidi's molasses? flavor.
And even so, since figs are so sensitive to environment, I'm almost wondering if Kathleen Black is better because it gets ripe better in your particular climate, or perhaps the tree gives better fruits, younger. The resources relating to figs now would have been awesome in the early '90s when we first planted those Petite Negris, especially in the sense that we might have gotten two different figs instead of two of one fig. Anyways, there doesn't really seem to be many elite figs older than about 5-7 years, and in many ways, this is an extremely young version of a very old hobby.