Bah...I ran into similar problems with his method. Leaves turned black on edges, and roots seemed to just die on me, rotting from the looks of it. I believe Rich's method works, but I don't know if its for everyone, for reasons I can't explain and won't attempt to (e.g. probably user error on my part)
In short, I scrapped it. I've had good luck rooting in sphagnum, but they seemed to halt or die when I put them in perlite. I switched media to 70% orchid mix 30% perlite, prewetted. Fantastic results so far, but it's only been a week. Four of my cuttings that had stalled out in perlite absolutely exploded with root growth in the orchid mix, and several others are doing well. Take everything I say with a grain of salt though...this is my first time doing this.
Anyways, edges of the leaves can turn brown from rot (humidity) or from drying out (from no roots). Mushy is often rot, dry is...well that's self explanatory.
Good luck!