The top photos definitely don't look like my F. afghanistanicas either. The leaves on mine are much more divided and serrated. I had three plants-- one from Forest Farm which looked exactly like yours but it died a couple of years ago for no reason I could find, and two that were purchased here in Texas--one at The Antique Rose Emporium and one at a local, small nursery. These two look identical to eachother with leaves much more divided and serrated than those in your pics.
The one I got from Forest Farm lived for about 3 years and never got leaves that resemble the other two I have now. Also, the 'trunk' and branches, if you can call them that, on my two remaining ones are much more slender than what your pictures show. Mine have never formed figs, but I am not really expecting them to. I just have them in with my other ficus varieties.
Back when I bought the one from Forest Farm, there was some question about the origin of their 'strain' of F. afghanistanica because the one I bought from them did not resemble at all the other two I had, and I had emailed them with some questions and concerns. If I recall correctly, the seed was supposed to have come from someone in Georgia (???) who brought it back from the middle east and gave seed to various people. I don't recall all the details, it's been too long, but the man I spoke to at Forest Farm was concerned enough that he emailed me and said he was going to research his seed origin further.
As far as I have been able to determine, the two I have that I purchased as F. afghanistanica do match other photos online, so I am reasonably sure the ones I have were identified correctly.
Also, they don't resemble the pic of the Afghan A at all.
I really NEED to figure out how to get pictures from my camera to the computer to here---it would be so much easier than trying to explain.