I got my Improved Celeste from James Robin 4 years ago, it didn't do much while I maintained it in a pot for three years, but now is in the ground and has grown very well. It is producing figs, but some have been dropping. I read that the IC had one to three lobed leaves, and the O'Rourke had five. My plant had been growing with 1-3, but now the new growth and suckers are producing 5 lobed leaves. So at first they looked like Gene's first two picks, but the growth now looks like O'Rourke in the third Gene picture. I also recall reading a post from Dan_la that the IC did not drop figs. Perhaps JR sold me an O'Rourke, I just don't know...I really like Pete's description of O'Rourke having a maple syrup flavor :)
Edit: after enlarging Pete's photos, I notice 3 lobed leaves are noted on O'Rourke. I have many three leaf and one single lobed with a small thumb. All new growth looks like O'Rourke. Then I re-read Mike's first post that his tree has 3-5, And that we bought our trees the same year.. My label from JR says Improved Celesete.
Mike in Hanover, VA