I have used straw jammed in between a fence around the tree, about 2 feet space between the fence and the tree, first I wrapped it with a burlap layer and covered the fence with burlap then a tarp, leaving a hole at the top, only a couple inches of die back on the newest growth, I did the same with leaves and also celulose insulation same results. I am doing this year cellulose on the small trees and the larger tree I just wraped with burlap, then bubble insulation (the silver sheets that come on a roll) then wrapped with a tarp, no hole. I have done the latter method on a 1 year old sapling with good results (I lost about a foot of growth on it though) this tree I did it on this year is 3 years old now, about 7 feet tall and wide. I think it should be alright, but we will see in spring. I also tried pete's method (ascpete) for the step over figs, I just drapped a blanket over top of the trees, then a tarp and secured it (only had manure and soil bags to make a nice tight fit. I will see how this does for me this year, I am hoping for good results as it is the easier method of all.