A couple things, it could be captan, it was a bit strong. I think you can only use this product about 3 times. Otherwise not sure what happened? It is a good idea to have a mulch ring, especially on young trees. It doesn't matter as much on older trees. Grass is excellent at nutrient gathering and can steal most of the nutrients. Very effective at out competing trees. Look for borer holes near the base too, any oozing of sap?