it seems to me, with the limited experience that I have, that some varieties last better than others. I'm QUITE sure some of the cuttings that I got were either older or poorly handled. The ones that were fresh and flexible seemed to have all shot out roots in the cloner, but some seemed dry and stiff from the git-go. The dry ones have been consistently doing poorly across varieties, but some varieties do seem to come around despite looking a bit haggard (RdB and VfB as examples). 3 years? Wow! I guess if they were very fresh, and waxed, ans sealed very good in plastic, and kept cold... they would certainly have a better chance at least! I'm interested in a couple of things. How were the cutting packaged (was the bag really tight? was it also wrapped in cellophane?), and how were they stored (temperature)?