I am sad to report I have not yet had a full season with any of them (only Brown Turkey and Celeste), and therefore can't compare. Of the list, I'm sure you noticed that none of them are in larger than 2gal pots. The only 2nd year fig I have is Hollier, and it had serious dieback, losing everything from 6" from the base of the main trunk. This was a purchase from James Robin - it was a great score for the price.
Our local farmer's market has a great variety of figs from everywhere, and this is the only way I know what flavors I like. I don't know many of the figs I have tried by name - it seems many are middle eastern figs, and not many have names that I see in the varieties page. They are very seasonal for fresh figs, too, so right now I only get dry ones.
I look forward to the coming season and hope that things go well with pot culture so I may reap the rewards of successful rooting and some of the year-end acquisitions. I also look forward to sharing some of the cuttings with the folks that have helped me out with acquiring varieties suited to my interest.