Sue, they aren't even ripe half dollar size! What could be eating them? YIKES! Ours is next to the chain link fence, so maybe that protects it from some critters.
We pick ours when they have a blush of pink, and we go down every day to check. They keep well in the fridge. I just make a ton of pie filling, and line pie tins with seran. Freeze the filling in the pie tin, and then just make crust and pop those frozen fillings already pie shape in there.
I really hope you get to taste yours this year. There is not a better apple!!
Suzi