Paul, I am so confused as to that also. In all Brazilian literature that I have read says to on the first year to choose the stronger shoot from the base, and that should be the main trunk, in other words, the rooted cuttings and other suckers would be cut off. I am yet to have to courage to do such pruning, but now that I have a few of same variety I am going to do that to one of them, so next year I will be able to compare.
there is a man named Bill in Seattle. He grows lots of figs and other fruits also. Once I visited him when his pear tree was in full production and I was amazed to his pruning. He does not cut the water shoots as everyone recommends, instead, those super strong shoots, he ties them and pulls them down. The water shoots had the most incredible size pears I ever seen. I am not sure it had any impact on the tree, as it was loaded with great looking fruit.
With Grapes, that is the recommendation also, keep 2 branches, until they reach trellis, in case one breaks, and only then, and one is cut out.