Frank, I like Excel but don't find it particularly outstanding. I've planted a variety of different figs mostly to see which ones work best in my area. I may not keep them all once I can evaluate them based on their long-term experience. They all seem to have drawbacks and advantages. Like everybody else, I'm looking for flavor, high production over a long season, good adaptation to local climate & soil, size, pest resistance, etc. I've had the Black Mission longest--probably around 18 years. I bought it and a Brown Turkey about the same time; the BT was prolific but after several years proved unsuitable because the open eye and internal void led to souring, due to insect activity--so I began looking for closed-eye varieties to take its place. That's when I discovered F4F and the dizzying number of figs out there. I kicked off my "collecting phase" in 2010 with a sizable UCD order and with beginner's luck had many of them survive; the rest of my figs came from subsequent trades and sharing from generous forum members and friends. I've discarded a few trees on purpose, had others die or perform poorly, and seen a few thrive; several are still too young for me to form an opinion.
Greenbud, my family eats quite a few figs, but I also share them with friends and dry them. I haven't made jam. All of my trees are still pretty small, either due to pruning or young age. Even the Black Mission is only 6 or 7 feet high having suffered a lot of frost damage, and looks more like a bush than a tree.
Katerina, I missed your response earlier. I don't think I'm doing anything special with my trees. I give them mulch, water, and not much else. I occasionally throw some fertilizer (whatever I happen to have on hand) under them if they look like they need it (mostly the Black Madeira, which remains stunted with FMV) but I don't notice much of a response. Mainly they want all the water I can give them.
After a few years, the ones that look healthiest/lushest in my yard are the Georgia White Hybrid, LSU Purple, Black Mission, Violette de Bordeaux, Hardy Chicago, and Marseilles Black VS (I can't tell any difference between the last two); others look promising but are still young. The differences in performance could be due to something as simple as local soil conditions--even moving a few feet can mean huge variations in the number of rocks or the depth of an impermeable caliche layer. Or, variations in watering, shade from adjacent trees, or who-knows-what-else could account for how my trees differ--I don't think it's all necessarily due to the variety.