Maggie,I agree,I also rated my Violette Number one in 2007,and now again in 2010.
But in 2008,when cold rainy Sommer it was bad,splitting totally and souring.
In 2009 it was average,in another cold rainy Sommer.
So yes it can be best in conductive hot dry Sommer and bad in rainy Sommer.
A Gardener outside ideal fig climate should not keep only one fig,and that one be Violette but another one that is constantly good,every Sommer,and then of course Violette de Bordeaux,just in case a good Somer is Coming.
In 2008 and 2009,many cultivars here were better than Violette:
From Top of my head:Malta Black,Tacoma Violett,Atreano,Marseilles vs black,Gino fig,Maltese Falcon,Celeste,Blue Celeste,Black Jack,Mission,and Many others,i can't remember,all.