Sarah, this is normal, leaves that form in the box, rarely make and new growth will appear. You leave them alone, I have a few that the sprout like yours, died, but the cutting was still firm, so I fluffed the soil gently around the cutting, to air it out more, and put that cover fo humidity. They are adjusting to light, moist, soil. lots to transition. Definately allow the soil to dry.. Make sure the new cups have plenty of holes, so they breath.
these look fine! they will recover. They don't like to be shaking and moving too much, I would just rotate the box around, so light gets them all. OH fig nurturing joy!