Gnat larvae are the issue. They can burrow into the cutting creating little pinholes that promote rot; also feast on young roots. Can really wreak havoc on cuttings. At the advice of many, I bought some Gnatrol powder (cheap on Amazon). I add about a cap or two to each gallon of water and bottom water my plants. I haven't had a huge gnat problem, but did it just to be safe. Not sure if its working, but haven't seen hardly a single gnat. So cheap, there's really nothing to lose by adding it to your regimen.