Encanto Farms Nursery > Categories > I'm under attack

Author Comment
Bass

Registered:
Posts: 2,428

Two days ago while watering my vegetable garden, a bird flew down and hit me on the head. I stopped I looked up and it was a Robin, I continued walking by my figs and the bird kept attacking me. I found the Robin nest in my grapevine near my vegetable garden and several of my figs. Yesterday it kept attacking me, and it seems that now the male is helping her with the attacks. My wife had to hold a stick to keep them from hitting me while I'm picking tomatoes and cucumbers. 

I feel bad, I know it's protecting its babies, but what got me mad is while my son was picking raspberries they were attacking him and my boy was running and screaming... 
Now we are being attacked every time we're in the garden. 
what would you do?

FrozenJoe

Registered:
Posts: 1,115

I would pick up the nest and move it somewhere else farther away from the garden.  I would wear a hat and work gloves and lots of clothes and have a helper with a broom.

rafed

Registered:
Posts: 5,308

Get a 12ga. with a modified choke and use some dove shots.
If the problem presists then move up to an extra full choke and triple XXX buck shots.
This should take care of the birds, the nest and the tree with one shot.

noss

Registered:
Posts: 2,122

RAFED!!!  NO!!!  Not a Robin!!!  They're usually not so aggressive like that.  I vote for relocating the nest somewhere safer for everyone.  :)

noss

satellitehead

Registered:
Posts: 3,687

Viv, I dunno about you, but Robins are DAMN aggressive here. 

The thing is, if they made a nest there one year, they will probably be back next year at the same location.  If moving the nest doesn't stop the attacks, shoot the bird.


Bass

Registered:
Posts: 2,428

I'm so afraid of coming anywhere near the nest... I don't know about re locating it... 

Are Robins edible?

OttawanZ5

Registered:
Posts: 2,551

I have a robin nest in a cedar hedge which belongs to my neighbour on the property line. It is next and close to my two sweet cherry trees and they don't have to go too far for their meals. They get to the fruit as soon the cherry ripen so now the few cherries left on the opposite side of the tree I get them when they are red i.e. before ripening (or else they are gone too). For whatever reason they are not attacking though.

possum_trot

Registered:
Posts: 224

I think that it is against the law to kill a song bird in this country, but baby birds mature really fast and will probably be gone within 2 weeks if you can wait it out.

Bass

Registered:
Posts: 2,428

I know it's against the law, we are joking. right Rafed?

I like birds, but this experience reminded me of the horror movie Birds by alfred Hitchcock. 

rafed

Registered:
Posts: 5,308

Yes, I like birds too.

tmc2009

Registered:
Posts: 854

Robbins are eating my blueberries so I'm building some more frames to hang the bird netting on.  My three year old grapevines are loaded with grapes this year too.  I'll need to cover them soon.  I took out a chipmunk today with my airmaster 77 bb gun.  Home depot had a new rat trap made of plastic thats like a foot pedal.  You use your foot to set it and no chance of getting your fingers caught.  I cut down my cherry trees.  Didn't get one cherry.  There was some kind of end rot and the birds and chipmunk got the rest.  They're too much work.  You have to prune them just right to get cherries.  I have redhaven peaches and golden delicious apples to replace them.

noss

Registered:
Posts: 2,122

How do you mean that Rafed?  Stewed, fried, smothered down with veggies?  LOL!

Our son used to go hunt blackbirds (starlings) with his friends and they would cook and eat them.  They had to have a mess of them for a good meal, but those are trash birds here and it didn't matter if anyone hunted them.

One time, Michael brought home half dozen little bird breasts (the only part that has any meat to speak of) and he happened to mention they were robins (they come down here for the winter, but don't nest here).  I wanted to skin him alive for killing robins.

Now my curiosity is piqued about the aggressiveness y'all have spoken of.  In NJ, if we would find a baby robin that fell from the nest too soon, we would rig up an old bird cage, or box and put the babies in there and the parents would just keep feeding it until it was old enough to fly off with them.  The parents didn't care how close we were to the bird cage, or box, they'd just go on into the cage and feed the baby right in front of us.

Maybe your robins have been hanging out with the mockingbirds and catbirds and bluejays.

I found a tiny baby bird one year and it didn't have any feathers on it yet, so I decided since there were all kinds of mockingbirds hanging around the baby and they were yelling, it must be a baby mockingbird, so I tried to give it to them by rigging up a box for its safety, but the mockingbirds wouldn't go anywhere near it.

I gave up and took the baby into the house to raise it myself, which I did, but before long, the baby started to put out some real feathers and they were blue!  It wasn't a mockingbird baby, it was a baby bluejay and the MBs and BJs hate each other with a passion.  The mockingbirds were wanting to kill the baby jay, not protect it and it never occurred to me that if it had been a baby mockingbird, I would have been dive-bombed by the whole lot of them. 

Yes, Bass, birds are edible.  Are you sure they're robins?  Brownish heads and backs with a rust-red breast for the male and dustier colors for the female?

Maybe NJ robins are just more gentle, or somthing because they used to make nests on our front porch and they were NEVER aggressive in any way, just sweet, gentle birds.  They weren't afraid of us and they didn't care if we were on the porch talking to them or watching them.

What does your kamakaze robin pair look like?

They sound like they're acting more like mockingbirds.  Now, you talk about attacks--They know now to do that.

I hope you'll relocate the nest and it will work out.

noss

TucsonKen

Registered:
Posts: 1,298

Very doubtful the parents would continue taking care of the kids if you move the nest. Birds tend to be more keyed in on location than on physical features, so their nest in the wrong place may no longer be recognizable to them as "their" nest.

TucsonKen

Registered:
Posts: 1,298

Noss, I started my post before you finished yours; it sounds like from your experience that maybe robins would deal okay with a relocated nest. Interesting solution!


Reminds me of a funny story--a former co-worker & bird watcher, who is quite tall, discovered a hummingbird nest in his back yard. His wife wasn't tall enough to look into the nest, and without thinking it through, cut off the branch with a pair of loppers so she could see if there were any eggs in the nest--which there were. She felt terrible once she realized what she had done, but they overlapped the branch where it had been cut and screwed it back together with drywall screws. A little shorter then it had been, but the hummers didn't seem to mind, and successfully reared their little brood.

noss

Registered:
Posts: 2,122

Hi Ken,

There are many old wives' tales around about birds and one is never try to put a baby bird back into its nest because after you touch it, the parents won't feed it again.  Not so.

Birds don't have keen sense of smell, so they don't smell us on the baby and most parent birds will feed their babies wherever they are found no matter what they have to do.  They know where those babies are.  I'm sure, if someone relocated a nest a long way from where it was originally, the parents might not hear their babies, or if they are just eggs, find the eggs.  Bass' robins sound like they'd be right there and would see where the nest would be relocated to, the way they are attacking them.

Sometimes, even if a parent bird is killed and there are babies, the other birds of the same kind will feed those orphaned babies.

Neat, eh?

noss

TucsonKen

Registered:
Posts: 1,298

One other thought (which is admittedly a big reach)--but do these birds always attack from behind? Some animals prefer not to face their "victims." I have a friend who does eagle research in many remote areas in the US and other parts of the world. We were once discussing mountain lion attacks, and he told be about a trick he picked up from rural people in some country I don't remember. He said they discouraged big cat attacks by wearing hats with wide open eyes painted on the backs, and he had started doing the same thing in mountain lion habitat. Many big cats prefer to ambush their victims and kill from behind with a bite to the base of the skull or back of the neck. I guess with "eyes in the backs of their heads", these folks didn't appear to be easy prey. Maybe you could scare these "raptor robins" with the same approach!

rafed

Registered:
Posts: 5,308

Ken,

I can honestly tell you when I was a kid I was attacked by a bunch of Blue Jays from behind.
I stole a baby Blue Jay and all hell broke loose.

I felt a couple pecks in the back of my head and neck.

Through it all I was Victorious!

TucsonKen

Registered:
Posts: 1,298

Rafed--those birds considered you a "suspect". ;-)

rafed

Registered:
Posts: 5,308

 Was caught red handed

TucsonKen

Registered:
Posts: 1,298

It's a good thing you only took a baby, and didn't try to run off with one of their fig trees instead!

rafed

Registered:
Posts: 5,308

LOL Ken

Dieseler

Registered:
Posts: 8,252

Bass the robins and Blackbirds here in my yard and on side of house do the same thing you describe mostly toward the dogs. They have yet to actually hit them but i have seen them go at the dogs mostly as they are walking toward the patio.
I have seen the baby birds learning to fly in our yard and they were just protecting them and i would shoe the dogs away. Luckily the small birds could take refuge up in the the evergreen bush out of there reach.

If moving nest is not an option -

What you can do is put a hose out in the yard you know kids love to play with the water hoses and when they see one of them birds let them have some harmless fun and in mean time i may keep the birds out of there way .

hoosierbanana

Registered:
Posts: 2,186

I think it's okay to move it. If they are that devoted they are going to follow you (pecking) the whole way. Maybe get a basket to put the nest in to make it easier to get up in the air and away from predators, if you could hoist it up higher into a shade tree maybe the adults would not be so tense. Protect your eyes!

I used to have a Carolina Wren that would nest in a hanging basket (that I then of course had to stop watering and let the passion flower die), and the light fixtures outside (that needed to have their bulbs removed). The worst part was she was always by the door and ended up inside a few times.

Birds are not smart, those robins picked a bad spot so in order to successfully raise their chicks they could really use your help. Cats and snakes could easily get the nest in a low spot like they chose.

Bass

Registered:
Posts: 2,428

I raise canaries, and if I ever touch a canary egg, the mother will abandoned  it. So I doubt it's a good idea to relocate the nest, I'm not even sure if their eggs have hatched.


Here's a black bird that I found in the garden. It was probably a baby. He did not mind going on my hand.



jusalda

Registered:
Posts: 152

Bass you must be living in paradise :)

FrozenJoe

Registered:
Posts: 1,115

Does it really matter that much if they abandon the nest? At least the problem will be gone and you won't have to use a firearm or bb gun near your home.

Figluvah

Registered:
Posts: 1,111

Bass,


After serious consideration and lotz of thought I have it all figured out, you need to feed that mama bird and her babies!

Feed them some #6- 410 bird shot.

rafed

Registered:
Posts: 5,308

I'm with Cecil,

hoosierbanana

Registered:
Posts: 2,186

I guess I should have done my googling first, glad you did not take my naive advice right away!

 Birds will abandon nests or eggs if they are disturbed, they are very visual and think there is a predator around. They can't detect human smells though, like Noss said, so your canaries must have noticed the eggs were in a different position. Robins can even detect other bird eggs in their nests because of their different shapes.

Robins nest 2-3 feet off the ground in bushes so that is the perfect spot for them. This is probably their second nest of the season and there may be other baby robins spread around from their first clutch still; they move babies out of the nest as they grow to separate locations.

Maybe they will get used to you? Or tired? Good luck.

fortisi876

Registered:
Posts: 81

Robins can be downright crazy at times.

A few yrs back, I had one that would perch up on the railing on my MBR balcony and just fly itself into the patio door then perch back onto the railing repeatedly it seemed until we got out of bed. I wasn't that upset about it until it got earlier and earlier as the days went by. No nest, no nothing, what in Gods earth did that thing want from us? :D

TucsonKen

Registered:
Posts: 1,298

They don't seem to tire easily. There was a mockingbird that used to drive me nuts when I was painting in the studio. At various times during the day it would perch on the window sill, and every 10 seconds or so would peck its reflection in the glass in an attempt to drive the "intruder" away. This "click" ... "click" ... "click" ...  went on for hours at a time, day after day, for several weeks, till I was expecting to see it with its beak worn down to a nub. Who knows why it finally stopped--maybe something ate it.

copperlilly

Registered:
Posts: 8

How about a water gun.

rafed

Registered:
Posts: 5,308

Are you referring to the water gun connected to a Fire truck?

copperlilly

Registered:
Posts: 8

That should work !

Bass

Registered:
Posts: 2,428

Well, just walked out to the garden and picked some brebas that were very ripe. The bird kept flying down like a missile and attacked me several times. At this point it's getting way annoying. I was about to through the large figs I just picked at it, wasn't even thinking. 

rafed

Registered:
Posts: 5,308

Bass,

Walmart has a nice pump pellet rifle with a tin of pellets and scope for under $50.

Just like on the other thread. Just a matter of time it attacks one of your kids and this time could be too late! Take care of the problem before the problem takes care of you.

Or just take the nest and put it else where far away and not worry about what happens.




satellitehead

Registered:
Posts: 3,687

Two words:  Tennis Racquet

If it doesn't learn after the first swipe, then keep going until it does.

noss

Registered:
Posts: 2,122

Ken,

That's what the people in India do.  They wear masks with faces painted on them, on the back of their heads.  They do that in an area along a river where the tigers love people meat.  I wonder what a bird would do?  It just might work, Bass.  Some bugs have big, fake eyes on parts of their bodies like that to scare predators away from them.

Rafed, don't you mean you were caught blue-handed?

Maybe New Jersey Robins are a cut above the Robins in other states?  :)

We had sweet Robins.  Are there different kinds of Robins in this country?  I never looked to see.  But Bass, you're just one state over from NJ.

I know--It HAS to be global warming effects upon their tiny brains.  Dries up their brain juices and makes them behave in bizarre ways.

Canaries are finches and Robins are thrushes.  (I love canaries)

Rather than shoot the Robins, I would move the nest and not worry about what happens.  It's not a good idea to let them stay where they are if there are kids that could be pecked and frightened.

Be glad, be VERY glad that you don't live here in the Land of the Mockingbird.  You talk about getting attacked!  Little feathered thugs and they steal all my figs, that the squirrel doesn't get!

noss


BLB

Registered:
Posts: 2,936

Get a cat, keep the canaries up high out of reach of said cat and enjoy your yard

rafed

Registered:
Posts: 5,308

Way to go Barry!

Tweety and Sylvester or I should say Thylvethter

texascockatoos

Registered:
Posts: 384

Motor Cycle Helmet.

TucsonKen

Registered:
Posts: 1,298

A tennis racquet Jason? I thought for birdies you needed a badminton racquet.


Not a bad idea, Cathy. One of the curators where I used to work was getting attacked every day by some kind of hawk (Coopers? I don't remember) that was nesting on her property, so she began wearing a bicycle helmet and wrapping her dashboard shade around her shoulders while running to and from the car in order to keep from getting injured. She said the first attack caught her unawares, and for a moment she thought someone had sneaked up and hit her in the back of the head with a club. Once she got to work, she discovered she still had a piece of talon embedded in her scalp.

My then 10-year old son got hit in the back of his neck and ear by an overly protective Harris hawk as he was shortcutting through a wash behind our house on his way home from school. Later I learned that mama hawk had been escalating the threat level each day, but he was ignoring the warnings. I suggested he change his route for a few weeks to give her time for an attitude adjustment, which did the trick.

satellitehead

Registered:
Posts: 3,687

I was going to say the same, Ken, but then I realized not everyone would know what badminton was.  I figured tennis is pretty universal.  I sacrificed the joke for the sake of understanding :(

TucsonKen

Registered:
Posts: 1,298

I should have known! At any rate, I'm rarely able to pass up a play on words (or is it birds?).

satellitehead

Registered:
Posts: 3,687

I'm right there with you.  One of my acquired (in-law) aunts and I have a special heart-to-heart relationship for puns and plays on words.  I LOVE it.  It takes a special, thoughtful and witty kind of person to be able to recognize it.

Please know that I appreciate you completely, brother.

TucsonKen

Registered:
Posts: 1,298

And a special kind of patient, long-suffering spouse to endure it. My wife has heard my puns so many times that her eyes start rolling before I've even recognized the opportunity to deliver one.

satellitehead

Registered:
Posts: 3,687

I feel your pain.

TucsonKen

Registered:
Posts: 1,298

No pain here--anyone who puts up with my sense of humor for that many years without demanding a refund is a treasure indeed!

JCA

Registered:
Posts: 65

Some birds like grackles and crows are actually very intelligent and can problem solve!  They can problem solve better than some people.

genecolin

Registered:
Posts: 1,542

hoosier I'll vouch for Rafed. A finer person I've never met. I'm not choosing sides but I think you carried this a little too far. It's sad a person who cannot see the humor in life or tolerate the humor of others. You make this sound like a personal vendetta against you. Maybe you should move on since you don't seem to fit here. Go eat some shrooms and you'll feel better.
"gene"  a proud and gentile member of f4f


  Show 57 posts from this topic on one page