My taste buds tell me there are a few broad groupings based on fig "TASTE":
1) The Celeste types .....Celeste, Improved Celeste, O'Rourke, Southern Brown Turkey, English Brown Turkey
2) The Mission types.......Black Mission, Violette De Bordeaux, Native Black, LSU Scott's Black
3) The Honey types......LSU Golden Celeste, Italian Honey, LSU Gold, Jack Lily, White Triana, Atreano, Florentine
4) The Black types.......Hardy Chicago, Sals, Sicilian Black, LSU Purple, Black Triana, Black Italian, Marseilles VS, Dark Portuguese, Gino's
5) The Adriatic types.......Smith, Dalmatie, Battaglia Green, Adriatic, JH Adriatc, Green Greek, Strawberry, Monstreuse
----------------------------------------------
IMO Everyone should have one from each taste grouping.
Col De Dame White....is hands down the best tasting fig in my collection. My in ground tree is VERY rain tolerant and my climate can ripen this fig to perfection.
Bourjosotte Gris runs a close second for taste.....it has a very strong strawberry flavor. Its productivity is still in question. It too is a LATE season fig.
Smith is often to die for good. It is a very well flavored, rain tolerant fig. As more growers taste this truly outstanding fig....you will hear them raving about its flavor.
IMO....Violette De Bordeaux is a MUST HAVE fig as it tastes so good and does well in most Climates.
Next for "taste" alone....would be a Louisiana heirloom Celeste fig that I found this past summer. I was in fig heaven for an hour as I ate some figs from the mother tree. Celeste figs can be to die for good.
-----------------------------
IMO, other factors should go into cultivar selection besides "TASTE" (flavor) alone. Ripening times, number of crops, productivity, rain tolerance, bug resistance, skin quality, sweetness, pulp consistency, fruit drop, size of tree, cold hardiness......etc. should also be taken into consideration.
When ALL of the above factors are considered, I highly recommend Joe Morle's White Triana to my neighbors. I am very pleased with the performance of that fig in my yard.
Dan