Figfan203
Registered:1391607592 Posts: 79
Posted 1393077784
Reply with quote
#1
What's the good and the bad for each rooting method? Is 1 faster than the other?
__________________ Mike in zone 6B
GRamaley
Registered:1357742252 Posts: 791
Posted 1393080604
Reply with quote
#2
I think the paper towel might be faster... I have had trouble with the water ones when transferring them to soil... I might have done it too soon when doing it on my own. I donated a bunch to a science glass and they rooted them in water with a grow light and as far as I know about 20 out of 25 have been doing great when transferred to soil. Here is that threadhttp://figs4funforum.websitetoolbox.com/post/help-with-classroom-project-now-w-photos-6620465
__________________ Gloria
---------------
7a, maybe 8
buonnatale2u
Registered:1299090139 Posts: 184
Posted 1393081108
Reply with quote
#3
I have read that when starting cuttings in water, it creates different types of roots that will have trouble adjusting to soil later on. I am sure one of the fig pros can write more about this. I personally would not use water to root fig cuttings.
__________________ Christy 7a/6b NJ
bonechickchris on GW
Wish List: Italian Purple Beefera-where are you?? :)
St. Rita, anything Belleclare, anything of the Salerno region of Italy
brianm
Registered:1389664758 Posts: 971
Posted 1393081151
Reply with quote
#4
Water: slow, no mold issues
Paper towel: fast,possible mold issues, root damage from towel
__________________ Wish list: Galicia Negra,UC Davis Black Ischia, Maltese Raven
Figfan203
Registered:1391607592 Posts: 79
Posted 1393082967
Reply with quote
#5
Ohhh I forgot about using sphagnum moss....
How's that compared to these other 2
__________________ Mike in zone 6B
brianm
Registered:1389664758 Posts: 971
Posted 1393084873
Reply with quote
#6
I have not had any issues going from water grown figs to dirt. Let me also say i been rooting only tip cuttings in water.
__________________ Wish list: Galicia Negra,UC Davis Black Ischia, Maltese Raven
GRamaley
Registered:1357742252 Posts: 791
Posted 1393089838
Reply with quote
#7
I prefer the moss...or almost straight perlite... look up Jon bag method..
__________________ Gloria
---------------
7a, maybe 8
rafaelissimmo
Registered:1335639347 Posts: 1,473
Posted 1393095079
Reply with quote
#8
I am using water, spaghnum and paper towel rooting methods. It is true water can take a while, but it depends on various factors, ie variety, quality of cuttings, and when the cutting was taken and what season you are in. Paper towel I think I am not too enthusiastic about even though it seems quite popular. I used a fungicide on cuttings and I still see mold issues in paper towel in baggie. As for spaghnum moss, I am having some success and will continue to root that way as well as with water. As for water, I use a bubbling system and aeration stone, I notice that the roots that this system produces can be quite vigorous and complex. I add nutrients and rapid start root enhancer to the water. Even so, the process can take a while, maybe a couple of weeks longer than other methods. I have lost a few cuttings after healthy roots grew and I transplanted into rooting medium. It may have been too moist so I am still working out the "stage 2" kinks.
__________________ Zone 7b, Queens, New York
Figfan203
Registered:1391607592 Posts: 79
Posted 1393107217
Reply with quote
#9
Raf-
What exactly do you add to the water?
__________________ Mike in zone 6B
rafaelissimmo
Registered:1335639347 Posts: 1,473
Posted 1393113505
Reply with quote
#10
I add cornucopia plus for nutrients, rapid start for roots, and a teaspoon of peroxide for disinfection.
__________________ Zone 7b, Queens, New York
rafaelissimmo
Registered:1335639347 Posts: 1,473
Posted 1393113541
Reply with quote
#11
And change the water once a week
__________________ Zone 7b, Queens, New York
GRamaley
Registered:1357742252 Posts: 791
Posted 1393118525
Reply with quote
#12
I'd love to see some pictures of that.
__________________ Gloria
---------------
7a, maybe 8
rafaelissimmo
Registered:1335639347 Posts: 1,473