Chateauguay_Pino
Registered:1393477334 Posts: 134
Posted 1394468702
Reply with quote
#1
I'm a big fan of Bone Meal for my mulberry and blueberry trees. Has anyone used it for fig tree's ? What are your thoughts ? I wouldn't mind knowing benefits or drawbacks to using it.
__________________ Canada - Zone 5a Wish List - Anything Italian. Calabria or Abruzzo regions.
SEGeo
Registered:1343244935 Posts: 517
Posted 1394470325
Reply with quote
#2
Chatueauguay Pino, The first question many will ask you is the acidity of your soil in the area of the fig trees. But, my main question toward the concerns is more on the line of what do you want the bonemeal to provide or do for your trees?
__________________ Chris Fairchild
Virginia Beach, Va.
USDA Hardiness Zone 8a
Graduate Student - Engineering and GeoScience
***I assume all my figs carry FMV***
Wish List:
Chateauguay_Pino
Registered:1393477334 Posts: 134
Posted 1394475057
Reply with quote
#3
Hi Chris, The natural soil around here is on the alkaline side Ph is around 9. I use peat moss to bring it down and i also add aluminum sulfate every 4 years or so. I do the same thing to get blue flowers from my hydrangeas. That said the tree's will be in pots with a customized soil mixture. (compost-potting soil-course sand-perlite) The bone meal i find gives me bigger blueberries. Same for the mulberries. I don't use miracle grow because i'm not sure if i trust what they're putting in there. It's great for the flowers but i'm just not sure i want to be eating it. Bone meal is organic and slow release.
__________________ Canada - Zone 5a Wish List - Anything Italian. Calabria or Abruzzo regions.
Chateauguay_Pino
Registered:1393477334 Posts: 134
Posted 1394475294
Reply with quote
#4
Thanks Doug. I figured it would be a good thing to add. I also love to use it and my father is much like you. He uses it on pretty much everything in his garden. He gets regular visits from everyone in the neighborhood asking how he gets his plants so big. Gotcha on the use sparingly. Thanks again.
__________________ Canada - Zone 5a Wish List - Anything Italian. Calabria or Abruzzo regions.
bullet08
Registered:1284496248 Posts: 6,920
Posted 1394477638
Reply with quote
#5
i grow my trees for height in first 2 yrs. didn't see much growth with organic things. will be moving back to MG and slow release fertilizer this yr. i heard others have very good results with bone meal, and blood meal.
__________________ Pete Durham, NC Zone 7b "don't talk to me about naval tradition. It's nothing but rum, sodomy and the lash." - sir winston churchill "the problem with socialism is that eventually you run out of other people's money." - the baroness thatcher ***** all my figs have FMV/FMD, in case you're wondering. ***** ***** and... i don't sell things. what little i have will be posted here in winter for first come first serve base to be shared. no, i'm not a socialist...*****
Chateauguay_Pino
Registered:1393477334 Posts: 134
Posted 1394479154
Reply with quote
#6
Thanks for the reply Pete. Seems like you didn't get good results from it. I guess different techniques work better in different areas.
__________________ Canada - Zone 5a Wish List - Anything Italian. Calabria or Abruzzo regions.
bullet08
Registered:1284496248 Posts: 6,920
Posted 1394482756
Reply with quote
#7
not really worried about die back. weather here is warm enough i don't worry about it. also, all my trees are container culture, so they spend their winter in my garage.
i'm sure i'm doing it all wrong, but i want my fig's to be at a height where i don't have to bend down to pick them. first two yrs, i get to that point.
so far it's been working for me :) nodes are not that far apart, and they are putting on branches for new crop... spring is when i push fertilizer. buy july/aug, i'm done giving them fertilizer.
__________________ Pete Durham, NC Zone 7b "don't talk to me about naval tradition. It's nothing but rum, sodomy and the lash." - sir winston churchill "the problem with socialism is that eventually you run out of other people's money." - the baroness thatcher ***** all my figs have FMV/FMD, in case you're wondering. ***** ***** and... i don't sell things. what little i have will be posted here in winter for first come first serve base to be shared. no, i'm not a socialist...*****
javajunkie
Registered:1362970391 Posts: 1,523
Posted 1394483945
Reply with quote
#8
Please share what you find Doug. I use bone meal, blood meal and bat guano but I'm always looking for something more "green".
__________________ Tami SE Texas
figgary
Registered:1387147322 Posts: 834
Posted 1394486829
Reply with quote
#9
I've used only natural fertilizers and amendments for 30+ years, with great results. For fig babies, I use fish emulsion, though the odor isn't good if your figs are inside. I add ground oyster shell, compost, and rock phosphate to potting soil when they go into pots. During the season I fertilize with fish meal, and or cottonseed meal, which is slightly acidic. I also top dress with more compost, which I make with horse manure and wastes from my garden. I've used the ground rock phosphate for many years, as an alternative to bone meal. It is supposed to break down slowly, releasing phosphorus for 3-4 years. Though new to growing figs, these things in one combination or another, always yield great results, as they feed the soil.
__________________ Gary in CA 9A Seeking: Bebera Branca*, Colonel Littman's Cross
Chateauguay_Pino
Registered:1393477334 Posts: 134
Posted 1394487101
Reply with quote
#10
Pete everyone has their own secret to success. I sincerely doubt your doing anything wrong at all. Your method of fertilization makes absolute sense. The more information from people that is out there the better it is for newbs like me. I appreciate your response. Doug, i like Tami would also like to know if you come up with anything.
__________________ Canada - Zone 5a Wish List - Anything Italian. Calabria or Abruzzo regions.
Ruuting
Registered:1359310699 Posts: 613
Posted 1394487554
Reply with quote
#11
Gary, good info on the rock phosphate. I'm very interested in this thread.
Doug, I'm listening (reading).
I have to do some research and be prepared when planting time comes.
__________________ Rui
Southeast CT, zone 6B
ascpete
Registered:1336096379 Posts: 1,942
Posted 1394491966
Reply with quote
#12
Chateauguay_Pino, I use Espoma-Tone Organic fertilizers with balanced nutrients and Mycorrhizae on all my plants both in ground and potted. For in-ground plants, I seed (inoculate) the soil in early spring with Espoma-tone and use compost as fertilizer. Bone meal is mostly P hosphorus, with some available Nitrogen and is more readily available in acidic soils, but needs to be broken down by soil microbes to become available to most plants. Most Espoma-Tone fertilizer products are now supplied with these microbes (mycorrhizae) that aid in that nutrient transfer. Bulb-Tone has additional bonemeal, Tomato-tone has additional Calcium but I use Garden-tone and Plant-tone. If you are using Bone meal, Limestone and other natural mineral fertilizers (non water soluble) please ensure that you have healthy microbes in the soil or potting mix to aid in the nutrient transfer to the plants. This is an Espoma webpage... http://www.espoma.com/p_consumer/tones_overview.html#.Ux4-ss4qDcs
jenn42
Registered:1389575153 Posts: 256
Posted 1394492044
Reply with quote
#13
Although I know absolutely nothing about fertilizing, I recently bought a "grow" pack for plumerias from a place online: http://www.kelp4less.com
They were fast with shipping and have a lot of stuff.
I am reading this thread to become more familiar with what figs need as far as fertilizer. I will check often in hopes of growing figs to their fullest.
__________________ Jenn
Austin, TX Zone 8b
Wish List: CDD, Bryant-Dark Unknown, Red Lebanese, ORoarke, Calvert
Will hopefully have cuttings to trade next year as my yearlings mature
rookie
Registered:1339168097 Posts: 384
Posted 1394501961
Reply with quote
#14
I didn't read this whole thread because I have to go out and and I'm not sure if anyone else mentioned this. Be careful of using bone meal if you have a dog that is in the same place as your trees. Bone meal + dog = dug up tree.
__________________ Scott, Long Island ,NY All my figs have been exposed to FMV,some have it, some don't. It doesn't seem to bother them so it doesn't bother me.
javajunkie
Registered:1362970391 Posts: 1,523
Posted 1394502589
Reply with quote
#15
Perfect Doug, thanks! OMG I never thought about dogs and bone meal, good tip!
__________________ Tami SE Texas
rafaelissimmo
Registered:1335639347 Posts: 1,473
Posted 1394506042
Reply with quote
#16
Sorry to sidestep the question, but just a thought: has anybody heard about adding gypsum to soil, it adds calcium, improves fruit quality and helps correct ph and improve drainage, so it could help fig trees I think, maybe like bonemeal or limestone?
__________________ Zone 7b, Queens, New York
Chateauguay_Pino
Registered:1393477334 Posts: 134
Posted 1394506795
Reply with quote
#17
Hi Rafael. Gypsum is the same stuff they make drywall from correct ? If so you are not the first person i have heard say it. Maybe others can chime in. Information is knowledge right.
__________________ Canada - Zone 5a Wish List - Anything Italian. Calabria or Abruzzo regions.
rafaelissimmo
Registered:1335639347 Posts: 1,473
Posted 1394508148
Reply with quote
#18
Drywall sounds gross. I saw this and it looked good: http://www.cmtmi.com/gypsum.asp
Also my hydroponic guy recommended gypsum and they are pretty conscientous.
__________________ Zone 7b, Queens, New York
Chateauguay_Pino
Registered:1393477334 Posts: 134
Posted 1394509171
Reply with quote
#19
Lol Rafael it may sound gross but pressed gypsum is what they use to make it. What i found most fascinating about the article is it's anti rotting properties. They actually use it to help prevent rot. That can't be a bad thing at all. (brain at work.... hmmm wonder if it would help with rooting) Thanks for that link. Very informative.
__________________ Canada - Zone 5a Wish List - Anything Italian. Calabria or Abruzzo regions.
ascpete
Registered:1336096379 Posts: 1,942
Posted 1394515042
Reply with quote
#20
Gypsum is used as a Calcium supplement for Alkaline soils while pulverized Limestone is used for Acidic soils. It the recommendation in most gardening literature. Quote:
In areas that get less than 20 inches of rain per year - Use Gypsum. In areas that get 20 or more inches of rain per year - Use Limestone... 0 - 19" = Gypsum , 20" ( or more) = Limestone
Dolemite Limestone is added to peat based potting mixes to increase pH, Calcium and Magnesium. Many Potting mix manufacturers will also add Gypsum to the mix to increase Calcium levels without increasing pH.
HarveyC
Registered:1212433117 Posts: 3,294
Posted 1394519675
Reply with quote
#21
Gypsum has no effect on pH. Some people say it does but that does not make it so.
__________________Harvey - Correia Farms Isleton, CA (Sacramento County) USDA zone 9b, Sunset zone 14
http://www.figaholics.com https://www.facebook.com/Figaholics
jdsfrance
Registered:1376988473 Posts: 2,591
Posted 1394552340
Reply with quote
#22
Hi, What I heard was : Bone meal + dog = dug up tree and dug down dog or cat. The pets would die if they eat too much bone/blood meal - which they should not do but pets are pets. Here they recommend to use the blood/bone meal at planting time - throw it in the bottom of the planting hole. It is supposed to be a slow release fertilizer - Meaning if you want the tree to grow fast - it won't be of much help. For figtrees I could use it as a base, but not alone ... To fertilize, I'm using compost - the same used for the winter protection -, manure, and chemical fertilizer for the garden. Last year I used castor bean oil pellets - but once again no cats or dog or child in the vicinity or you might be in trouble - during the first two weeks ... Rodents get in trouble with it - and that was the reason for using that last fertilizer !
__________________ ------------------------
Climate from -25°C to + 35°C
Only cold hardy figtrees can make it here
Chateauguay_Pino
Registered:1393477334 Posts: 134
Posted 1394553599
Reply with quote
#23
I tend to agree with Doug. The bone meal is usually used at the bottom when you are first planting the tree or potting it. The amount of it used isn't usually very much you don't need alot of it. I too have had dogs all my life and never had anything like that happen. That's not to say it doesn't happen. If people are saying it then I'm sure it does in fact happen. Dogs will eat just about anything and if they like it they will always go back for it. One of my dogs used to eat at my lilac tree. He for whatever reason loved the leaves. Threw up after every time but he didn't care. The vet said it was somewhat toxic but on the low end of the scale. He lived to be 16. Not bad for a Husky.
__________________ Canada - Zone 5a Wish List - Anything Italian. Calabria or Abruzzo regions.
Chateauguay_Pino
Registered:1393477334 Posts: 134
Posted 1394553780
Reply with quote
#24
Bonjour JDS Yes it will be at the base of the container in a mixture of compost, potting soil, course sand, and perlite.
__________________ Canada - Zone 5a Wish List - Anything Italian. Calabria or Abruzzo regions.
FigTrees2013
Registered:1371525269 Posts: 66
Posted 1394586993
Reply with quote
#25
I always use bone meal for my fig trees - particularly since I grow them all in pots. I've had great success and would definitely recommend it as an organic supplement.
__________________ Zone 6b
ejp3
Registered:1193140374 Posts: 668
Posted 1394596847
Reply with quote
#26
I used to use it but the thought of contributing to the grinding down of animal bones and small possibility of contracting mad cow disease are enough for me use other soil additives.
__________________ Ed NY zone 7 Wish list CDD Blanca/Negra
Chateauguay_Pino
Registered:1393477334 Posts: 134
Posted 1394637899
Reply with quote
#27
I had to look this one up. Read this article. Very very interesting.http://www.organicconsumers.org/madcow/fertilizer1804.cfm
__________________ Canada - Zone 5a Wish List - Anything Italian. Calabria or Abruzzo regions.
Chateauguay_Pino
Registered:1393477334 Posts: 134
Posted 1394638379
Reply with quote
#28
It's actually a great alternative for those people who are worried. I think bone meal is safe enough for me to continue to use it. I read on the container and it does say organic. The last line in that article pretty much sums it all up. "Honestly, the chances of getting killed using a rototiller are a lot greater."
__________________ Canada - Zone 5a Wish List - Anything Italian. Calabria or Abruzzo regions.
Chateauguay_Pino
Registered:1393477334 Posts: 134
Posted 1394639082
Reply with quote
#29
Looks like a good product Doug. I also noticed they recommend mixing it thoroughly throughout the soil rather then at the bottom like bonemeal. Would be interesting to know the results.
__________________ Canada - Zone 5a Wish List - Anything Italian. Calabria or Abruzzo regions.
Chivas
Registered:1283819505 Posts: 1,675
Posted 1394643936
Reply with quote
#30
I use bone meal, and this year it will be a mix of blood bone meal and potassium sulfate. If you have a problem with animals (racoons, cats and dogs) you can use products like calphos which is a soft rock phosphate which will give your phosphorus as well as calcium for them trees.
__________________ Canada Zone 6B
ejp3
Registered:1193140374 Posts: 668
Posted 1394662879
Reply with quote
#31
I said "small possibility", that's good enough for me.
__________________ Ed NY zone 7 Wish list CDD Blanca/Negra
Chateauguay_Pino
Registered:1393477334 Posts: 134
Posted 1394663310
Reply with quote
#32
Plenty of comments for and against. All of them have great points. The key is to educate ourselves. I have already learned quite a bit including about new products.
__________________ Canada - Zone 5a Wish List - Anything Italian. Calabria or Abruzzo regions.