eboone
Registered:1378418906 Posts: 1,101
Posted 1395013790
Reply with quote
#1
For our potting media we add course inert perlite, we add pelletized limestone for pH and Calcium. Would there be a point in adding limestone gravel for outdoor potting media? Could be a long term source of calcium. Could add some weight for better or worse.
Any thoughts on this?
__________________ Ed Zone 6A - Southwest PA --------------------------- Short wish list: CDDG, LSU Red, Dark Greek (Navid), Col Littman's Black Cross . And any cold hardy early fig.
Rewton
Registered:1291943117 Posts: 1,946
Posted 1395020305
Reply with quote
#2
I've always wanted to do this but I haven't found a source of limestone gravel locally. There have been some previous discussions on the forum about this. I believe the Belleclare nursery folks used to recommend putting down a layer of limestone gravel over the top of their fig containers.
__________________ Steve MD zone 7a
blake
Registered:1392690363 Posts: 16
Posted 1395025678
Reply with quote
#3
Make sure you understand what your soil pH is before you start trying to alter it. As a fig newbie, I'm a little confused by the prevalent "figs prefer alkaline soil" messages because it seems most formal documentation I see online suggests a slightly acidic pH of 6-6.5. Adjusting soil pH too high can high block absorption of iron and manganese.
Tam
Registered:1365478628 Posts: 1,084
Posted 1395026666
Reply with quote
#4
Thank you for sharing. Steve: I am like you and I have not seen any limestone locally too. I will go to the Home Depot this spring to see if they carry them. Best, Tam
javajunkie
Registered:1362970391 Posts: 1,523
Posted 1395045307
Reply with quote
#5
I have been coating the top of my pots with limestone and have gotten very good results. Added benefit is it keeps the weeds down and insects don't seem very fond of it either. Blake, there are tons of pictures of fig trees growing straight out of limestone in their native habitat so I don't think some in the pot will hurt anything. I found after adding it my trees took off.
__________________ Tami SE Texas
elin
Registered:1360863025 Posts: 1,272
Posted 1395053225
Reply with quote
#6
I would check how much calcium is in your water, here my water is full with Ca so i dont add lime.
__________________ Eli ,Israel ,Zone 10? Too humid and hot, yada yada yadahttps://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1298814119 Growing : Sbayi, Hmadi, Black Portugal, Black Brazil,Excell, Flanders, Hmari , RDB, Niagra Black,Natalina, CDDN,Maya, Preto Torres, Preto Arge
jdsfrance
Registered:1376988473 Posts: 2,591
Posted 1395064087
Reply with quote
#7
Why not put directly fertilizer ? if your goal is to feed the tree. You could use pine bark as mulch upon the dirt . On the "Pont du Gard", there are fig trees growing - it is an old Roman brigde in southern France.
__________________ ------------------------
Climate from -25°C to + 35°C
Only cold hardy figtrees can make it here
blake
Registered:1392690363 Posts: 16
Posted 1395072671
Reply with quote
#8
I appreciate the input and the teaching. If there’s one thing I’ve gleaned thus far about figs is that they are highly adaptable. They can survive and even thrive in a broad range of soils.
With so many cultivars of ficus carica coming from wide-ranging environments (soil conditions) it makes sense that some would develop a preference for certain soil conditions. Just like some cultivars are hardier than others.
But I really am curious about choices the collectors here make and why they make them, especially with regards to soil chemistry.
When I read a reference to Belleclare Nursery in Plainview, NY suggesting a layer of limestone gravel on top of figs, it got me thinking. I wonder is that because:
1) They think all figs prefer higher pH soil?
2) Maybe it’s just the cultivars they sell?
3) Maybe it’s because the soil in that area is very acidic and the limestone is needed to reach a more neutral pH for the figs? (Check any number of Long Island area lawn care service websites and they all speak to regular application of lime in order to balance the soil pH for lawns.)
I’ve developed a theory… Maybe the gravel suggestion is less about soil pH (unless you’re dealing with soil pH below 6) and more about a different set of benefits including:
1) Improved drainage
2) Reflect light and heat up to the plant
3) Retaining and radiating heat to aid the ripening process
4) Encouragement for roots to dig deeper to find nutrients
5) Assist in water retention
I think #2 and #3 are particularly import for the many people here with cooler temperatures and shorter growing seasons.
No doubt soil pH and mineral content is also going to have an impact on taste so maybe that’s at play here too. As I learn about more about figs it seems there’s a lot to be learned from the practices of growing grapes for wine(?).
Again, I sincerely appreciate the input of this forum as I learn about figs.
ascpete
Registered:1336096379 Posts: 1,942
Posted 1395074630
Reply with quote
#9
Ed, I have grown cuttings in 50% Granular limestone without any major issues. It was only a test, but it can be done for potted culture. The Granular limestone can be be rinsed initially to flush out the dust and reduce the pH. I've measured a 8.9 pH in an agitated Dolemite Limestone solution, with water at 6.9 pH. Blake, Adding small amounts of Dolemite limestone to soil only slightly increases the pH. The Bellaclaire Figs were grown in Peat based potting mixes which typically would benefit from an increase in pH, but by adding Granular limestone (larger grain) as a topping they actually increased the pH less, but increased the Calcium and Magnesium levels. Even adding yearly limestone applications to my garden soil has only slightly increased my pH less than 1 point. In potted culture increased watering will flush out the limestone and decrease the pH quickly until the pH levels approach that of the water. The increase in pH is much higher when using processed Lime products (quick lime, Hydrated lime, etc) which should not be used unless you are experience with their application, they are up to 15 times more potent that Pulverized Limestone, very caustic and will cause plant damage if not used properly. Your list of added benefits may all be possible. BTW, I add 1 cup of pelletized or pulverized Dolemite Limestone per 5 gallons of potting mix, with 1/2 cup added monthly for 3 months the ratios and mix are described here... http://figs4funforum.websitetoolbox.com/post/show_single_post?pid=1278563825&postcount=16 .
recomer20
Registered:1378013757 Posts: 402
Posted 1395369896
Reply with quote
#10
I put some crusher run in the bottom of my cups...observed that the lime dust does leach out and form a chalky crust in bottom of cup...thought that might be a problem for drainage and repotted. I usually mix in a handful of crusher run into 1g and larger now; hard to say whether it benefits are not.
__________________ Rick C. Birmingham, AL z7b --- *INGROUND: S.C.Lemon ("Dr.Welch"), LSUpurple, Celeste (Std) *POTTED 3rd Yr: Alma, Atreano, BattGreen, GrnGreek, HardyChicago, ItalianBlack (Becnel), LSUGold?, MBvs, Sal's EL, Southern BT?, St.Jean, Jackie'sUnk *POTTED 2nd Yr: SunbirdUnkJP, BourjNoire, JHAdriatic, ValleNegra *ROOTING: RdB, ScottsBlk, BlkGreek-MN,Preto
eboone
Registered:1378418906 Posts: 1,101
Posted 1395774393
Reply with quote
#11
Rick - what is 'crusher run'? Some type of crushed limestone or gravel?
__________________ Ed Zone 6A - Southwest PA --------------------------- Short wish list: CDDG, LSU Red, Dark Greek (Navid), Col Littman's Black Cross . And any cold hardy early fig.
Ampersand
Registered:1389979527 Posts: 728
Posted 1395777834
Reply with quote
#12
If you are looking for gravel, most block companies or stone places have limestone screenings. It's basically very fine limestone gravel. A place near me sells it for $16/ton (not a typo). I don't know how much this would affect soil pH since I think limestone needs acid (rain is mildly acidic, or strongly in areas with acid rain) to dissolve and be chemically active...not a quick fix. If nothing else it would help with drainage and add weight if wind is an issue blowing containers over. Funny, I was just pondering this the other day if adding screenings to mixes or in planting holes would be beneficial.
recomer20
Registered:1378013757 Posts: 402
Posted 1395796492
Reply with quote
#13
Crusher run is crushed limestone chips...smaller than gravel and usually jagged. We use it on garden paths to keep mud down.
__________________ Rick C. Birmingham, AL z7b --- *INGROUND: S.C.Lemon ("Dr.Welch"), LSUpurple, Celeste (Std) *POTTED 3rd Yr: Alma, Atreano, BattGreen, GrnGreek, HardyChicago, ItalianBlack (Becnel), LSUGold?, MBvs, Sal's EL, Southern BT?, St.Jean, Jackie'sUnk *POTTED 2nd Yr: SunbirdUnkJP, BourjNoire, JHAdriatic, ValleNegra *ROOTING: RdB, ScottsBlk, BlkGreek-MN,Preto