Encanto Farms Nursery > Categories > --- measuring the soil temp in the pots

Author Comment
greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

A few days ago there was a thread that started me thinking to measure the pot temperature:
http://figs4funforum.websitetoolbox.com/post/OT-Lowes-Haul-Today-6471924

After trying with an average thermometer, I decided that this must be done more scientifically.
So what I will try to do is the following.
I have ordered this kit with 4 sensors:
http://store.qkits.com/moreinfo.cfm/VK011

T
his will allow me to collect 4 sets of continuous data sampling every 5 min, for example. I was thinking about these locations:
1- terracotta pot
1- black nursery pot
1- directly in the soil
1- in the shade under a tree (ambient temp)

I am going to run this for 24 hours and see how the temperatures compare to each other.

What do you think?
Any suggestions?

Anybody has an experience using the DS18S20 sensors? Its specs are pretty good:

  • Measures temperatures from –55°C to +125°C (–67°F to +257°F)
  • ±0.5°C accuracy from –10°C to +85°C

greg88

Registered:
Posts: 800

be interested to see results

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Greg,

Yes, of course I will share the results. That's the plan!

JustPeachy

Registered:
Posts: 304

I wish you would try one of these fabric pots too. I think they're really neat.

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Sophie,

That's an idea! But the board can accommodate 4 sensors only. So I have to come with a strategy here. Maybe 1 day like what I mentioned above and 1 day with a fabric pot instead of whatever I decide is a clear outlier  after the first test.

Dieseler

Registered:
Posts: 8,252

Yes if you can compare same size containers on same surface next to each other with same potting mix and similar moisture content.

SoniSoni

Registered:
Posts: 777

 That's a great project!   When I read the previous post about black pots getting hot I checked mine and YEOW! I was shocked how very hot.  I'm very interested in your results of temps inside the pots.    I was thinking to painting some pots white but ran accross these white sleeves to slip over black pots.  i ordered some in different sizes. They didnt come yet.  but easier than painting.
Soni

http://www.amazon.com/ViagrowTM-gallon-Grow-Bag-pack/dp/B00BAZT1N6/ref=sr_1_5?ie=UTF8&qid=1376681634&sr=8-5&keywords=white+grow+bags

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Martin,

Since you started talking the details here, that was my version 1:

Case 1, use the dry sand from Home Depot. It is cheap, clean and homogeneous.
2 gal pots for terracotta, plastic and now fabric.
Bury the sensors at the 6 inch depth in the soil and pots, 3 inch from the pot's side.
I have a spot on my concrete patio large enough to put the pots next to each other so the difference is minimal.
Start at 4 or 5 am when the temp is approximately the same. Run for 24 hours at least.

Case 2.  The same as the Case 1 but put the pots on the grass. Dry sand.

Case 3. The same as the Case 1 but add 2 cups of water. On concrete.

Case 4. The same as the Case 1 but saturate the sand with 1 gal of water. On concrete.

Obviously, one can come up with many more scenarios but this should keep me busy for a while.
Also, it is possible that the Cases will be modified as I proceed.



Grasa

Registered:
Posts: 1,819

I would think it matters against the hot California sun and hot air that most of us don't have. Also, should try under some leaves/semi-shade.

Tonycm

Registered:
Posts: 922

Greenfig you might want to check the wind speeds. On a calm day I would suspect the pots would retain more heat than if it was very windy. I'm sure there are other variables that could affect the temps in the pots.

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Tony, That is the only thing that would be hard to measure. My yard has a 5 ft fence around it + many trees so almost no wind at the ground level. I also don't have a wind sensor, need to get one that works with a USB or serial connection. The question is very valid though, I should try to incorporate the wind too.

ascpete

Registered:
Posts: 1,942

Greenfig,
Good luck with your tests.
From past experience growing vegetables in containers, any container temperature above 100 deg F is bad for plant growth. Attached are a few documented tests.
This Kansas State Thesis has several pictures descriptions and tables of test procedures and results.
 
[QUOTE]After four months (June-October), plant variables were measured. Roots were separated into three sections: core (10.2 cm diam.), north, and south, rinsed of all media, dried and weighed. In the bean study, media temperatures at the sun-facing side averaged lowest in gloss and flat white (~36 oC) and greatest in the black control (50.3 oC). Accordingly, total root biomass at the sun-facing side was reduced by 63 to 71% in black compared to flat and gloss white containers. In heat-sensitive maples, media temperatures at the sun-facing side averaged up to 7.7 oC greater in black, black shade and green than in other treatments; temperatures in black shade may have been lower if shade cloth had covered the sun-facing sides of containers in addition to only the media surface. Media temperatures in the core averaged 3.5 to 3.8 oC greater in black than in flat and gloss white, resulting in up to 2.5 times greater below ground biomass and up to 2.3 times greater above ground biomass in flat and gloss white than in black pots...

At temperatures over 30 oC, root growth slows considerably (Johnson and Ingram, 1984). For many woody species root growth will stop completely at temperatures above 39 oC (Mathers, 2003). The roots of some woody species (e.g., Ilex crenata ‘Helleri’) die when exposed to temperatures of 51 oC for merely thirty minutes (Martin et al., 1989). Studies have revealed that temperatures inside nursery containers can rise much higher than 51oC, and commonly surpass 54 oC in the southern states (Ingram et al., 1989; Martin et al., 1989) (Mathers, 2000).
[/QUOTE]
Note:
30 deg C = 86 deg F
39 deg C = 102 deg F
51 deg C = 124 deg F

7deuce

Registered:
Posts: 566

Good luck with your experiment.

I have my own theories on plastic pots and temperature. I believe in small black plastic pots( 1-5 gallon )the bulk of the roots push through the soil and congregate around the black plastic. If the pots aren't shaded then the black plastic cooks the roots touching the plastic severely stunting the growth of the plant.

As a side note, I use fabric pots on all small plants now.

james

Registered:
Posts: 1,653

My experiences mirror Jason's. I grew a tree in a five gallon, white bucket while in Houston. When I removed the tree from the bucket, there were roots extending beyond the growing mix on half, but no more than 2/3 of the distance on the other. All of the cuttings I rooted this year are in 1 and 2 gallon Root Pouch (fabric) containers and sitting on a table under partial shade. Yesterday while tending to them, I noticed a significant difference in the temperature and weight ( moisture level) of the trees on the south side of the table than those just one row in. The table they sit has a steel mesh top so air circulates under the containers, but that does not seem to dissipate enough heat from those containers on the south side. I think it would be interesting to measure how much of an effect watering at different times has on the overall temperature and peak temperatures in the containers. To my mind, the ability to control temperature by daily watering is the biggest advantage of a fast growing mix (especially in the south). I'm curious how accurate it is. ~james

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Pete, Jason, and James,

Thank you for your feedback. It seems quite a few people grow the figs in pots and I am glad that my data might be interesting to the fig community!

I am happy to say that I received the board with one sensor (the other 3 sensors have been shipped separately).
I am testing it now and it works great! It reports the temp in C and F from 1 sec to 99 min (selectable).
I set it to 5 min for now just to play with the device.

It is happening!!

Please see the board in the photo attached. The sensor is a black chip attached to the blue terminals at the bottom. I have a 100 ft cable, the sensors will be soldered to the cable when they arrive.
The data sample in on the screen. It doesn't log the time so I have to record the start time but that is not a big deal.

susieqz

Registered:
Posts: 971

greenfig, great idea. i'm looking forward to seeing the results.

but, where do i find out best temps for container soil for figs?

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Susie,

At the moment, I don't have an answer for you. That would require some basic research with googling.
I am sure somebody here knows what would be the best temp for the container figs.

My initial goal was to find/measure the temperature ranges for different container types after I discovered how hot was my terra-cotta pot with an unhappy kumquat in it.

susieqz

Registered:
Posts: 971

i get it, green. i would have thot a terra cotta pot with the ability to breath would always be cooler than plastic. i really need to see your results.

james

Registered:
Posts: 1,653

The science community has stated above 85F and the plant starts suffering due to roots loosing efficiency.

susieqz

Registered:
Posts: 971

thanks james. now i'll be able to put green's research into context.

green, please don't forget to post results.

JustPeachy

Registered:
Posts: 304

[QUOTE=james]The science community has stated above 85F and the plant starts suffering due to roots loosing efficiency.[/QUOTE]

And this amazes me because terracotta has been holding thriving plants long before plastic nursery pots were invented! I mean look at Europe. They've been using clay pottery for ages with no ill effects.

james

Registered:
Posts: 1,653

I'm sorry, Sophie. I should have said "when temps in the root zone approach 85F the roots' efficiency start to decline." Having said that, terra cotta does keep the root zone cooler than black plastic.

ascpete

Registered:
Posts: 1,942

Any probe style thermometer (cooking or oral) can be used to get a quick check of the soil temperature, you would be surprised at how hot the roots get in most containers.

Soil temperatures to keep in mind:
50 deg F to 80 deg F   = Normal root growth.
85 deg F to 100 deg F = Slow or no root growth.
110 deg F and over     = Root die back

Figfinatic

Registered:
Posts: 761

Very interesting experiment.  Will be good to know your results of the variation between pots.  

My unheated pool temp currently reads 95 degrees at 9pm at night, so my fig pot temp must be well above 85 in the day and night.  I've got plenty of growth and figs.   For instance, my desert king that I started this winter is already my tallest fig grown in a pot.  It's over 7 feet already even after pinching.   

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Hi all,

I have the first results to report!
I was surprised how HOT was the medium inside!! Please see the plot and the photos.

The fabric was the hottest, black plastic was next and the terra-cotta was the coolest but the was no direct sun almost all day!! Tomorrow might be a different day.
Inground soil was quite cool so there is a huge benefit to bury the pots!

The setup:
- 4 sensors were soldered to 15 ft long cables and waterproofed with epoxy;
- the black cable markings correspond to 5,10,15,20 cm, the depth indicators;
- used 3 x 2 gal pots, black fabric, red terracotta, and black nursery plastic;
- one sensor is in the inground soil, a loan with grass;
- data collection: every 5 min for 24 hours, from 10 pm to 10 pm approx.;
- dry silica sand from Home Depot was used as a medium;
- the sensor depth at all 4 locations was 10 cm (4 inches);
- the pot orientation was West-East on the South side of my house;
- the day turned out to be very cloudy (the first like this during the entire summer!!);
- the direct sun exposure is approx. 10 am -5:30 pm, but it was on and off often;
- absolutely no wind;
- the measurements are in C, the C-F table is on the plot.

Next:
a) tomorrow is supposed to be a sunny day, I want to see how bad it would get with the dry sand.
b) add 1/2 gal of water to each pot and measure the difference.
c) replace the sand with some real fig soil, measure the temp.

Enjoy! I appreciate your feedback

Maro2Bear

Registered:
Posts: 732

Greenfig, Nice experiment that you have going here. It will be interesting to see the temps on a sunny hot day! Tks for sharing your info.

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Sure, Mark. Now I am more curious than before to try with the real soil. I think the results will be different because the soil density and heat capacity are different.

ascpete

Registered:
Posts: 1,942

Greenfig,
Thanks for posting the results.
I'll be watching for updates and future experiments.

cobb4861

Registered:
Posts: 537

You know something that might need to be compared is the soil temp inground compared to the containers.

susieqz

Registered:
Posts: 971

green, now that you have the equipment, may i suggest another test? i think it would be very interesting to measure the temps in two identical pots, one on pavement, one on soil. i have been warned about placing pots on pavement.

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

[QUOTE=cobb4861]You know something that might need to be compared is the soil temp inground compared to the containers.[/QUOTE]

Cobb4861,

On the plot, the purple line is the temp in the inground soil, in my loan with grass, for a comparison.
I am sorry if that was not clear, I will try to explain better.

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

[QUOTE=susieqz]green, now that you have the equipment, may i suggest another test? i think it would be very interesting to measure the temps in two identical pots, one on pavement, one on soil. i have been warned about placing pots on pavement.[/QUOTE]

Susie,

Yes, that is coming! I am interested to know how substantial is the difference too.
The pavement radiates the heat a lot and long after the sun is down.

cobb4861

Registered:
Posts: 537

Just read back thru and saw that. Your doing a great job!

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Hi,

Here is the results of the Test 2. It is very similar to the Test 1, the only difference is the weather. It was very sunny all day, very hot with max temp at 36C or 97F :(
Today was a perfect day to bake my imaginary figs..

To remind the setup: 3 pots are on the concrete on the South side of my house filled with the dry sand.
The data collection is every 5 min from the sensors buried 10 cm in the center of the pots. The control sensor is in the ground at 10 cm depth.

Max temp for the fabric pot: 51C or 124F
Max temp for the terra-cotta pot: 46C or 115F
Max temp for the plastic pot: 50C or 122F
Max temp for the unground sensor: 30C or 86F

The best performing pot is terra-cotta, the worst: fabric.

Now I feed sorry for my real figs that are about 5 feet away. They are not growing fast enough and now I know why!
I am surprised they are not dead. It is the time to save them. 

Please see the figure attached.

Tomorrow I will add the 1/2 gal of water to the sand and that will be all for the sand. I need to buy a bag of soil to try the soil on the concrete and on the grass.

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Wow, the forecast today is 37C or 98.6F and those high temps are going to be around all September.

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Hi again,

Please see my final report on the temp testing in the silica sand.
I joined all 3 test (today's and the previous ones) on one plot.
The Test 3 was with the water saturated sand that I added last night, the pots were still on concrete.

The results are very interesting for me.

Some points:
The atmospheric temperature was higher than yesterday (see the green line for the soil temp) but the pot temps were much lower! My explanation is that the water evaporation cools the media down, by a lot!  And in different ways for different pots.

The largest impact was on the fabric pot. Its highest temp today was 35C vs. 52C yesterday! Wow! That is 13 degrees!

The terra-cotta dropped 6 degrees (40C today).

The plastic dropped only 4 degrees (46.5C today).

So, if you want to keep your figs happier in the hot climate, water them well! 

It seems there is a huge benefit in growing the figs in fabric. They provide enough oxygen and cooler when watered.

The black plastic pots need to be shielded from the sun, the plants will just cook there.

I will try on the grass and with the real soil next.

Enjoy!

P.S. Two figures attached are the same but one is larger if you want to see more details. It is better to do this in a separate window. Or as snagplus is saying:
TO ENLARGE THESE PICS, MOUSE OVER, RIGHT CLICK, OPEN IN NEW TAB OR WINDOW

elin

Registered:
Posts: 1,272

Thanks for the sharing.This place takes a step further with your analysis
probably thats why the japanese di it like in the picture with fabric supported by plastic pots like the ones used for chicken live stock.

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Thanks, Eli! Interesting idea, and a cheap one, fabric in plastic crates.

elin

Registered:
Posts: 1,272

Found it on ken love website http://www.hawaiifruit.net/

http://www.hawaiifruit.net/figstation/index.html 
I think we should do the same experiment and compare the state among different pots.

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Good experiments require a good preparation :) I discovered that it was a little challenging to find different 3 pots of similar shape and size in my area (without going far and order online paying extras). But hay, it is all fun now since I know how to do it :) Even more, yesterday I found a way how to get 5 min interval data from my local weather station about a kilometer away so now I can compare the soil temps with the ambient air temp. Care for an extra line on the plots?

elin

Registered:
Posts: 1,272

probably a direct relation?

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Almost direct, you will see a delay at night since the air temp cools down quicker.

cis4elk

Registered:
Posts: 1,719

Great information. Keep up the good work!

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Thanks! 
It is hot like hell today.
I didn't have time to get the soil and just put the pots with sand on the grass and watered them.
I will post the wet-sand-on-grass results tonight. Stay tuned!

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Ok, here is the last sand measurement plot!
I joined all 4 days in one figure.
The today's numbers were collected on the loan grass and, as you have already probably known, you figs are the happiest there!

Looking at the green line of the soil temps you can tell that today was as hot as yesterday, which allows you to directly compare today's grass with yesterday's concrete temps.
The difference is huge and the temps for the terracotta and fabric pots are very close to the soil temp.
The plastic pot temp sucks big time. Although it is still lower than on the concrete, it is much worse than anything else.

My thoughts: People always go around blaming one pot or another but at the end it seems the cheapest one wins (i.e. a black nursery ).
I think the pot selection should depend on your climate. I don't think mine in LA would be suitable in the same way in Maine, for example. The temp, precipitation, and humidity are totally different. As you can see from the plots, the watering and the pot placement location make a huge difference too. As far as the soil selection goes, I will try to test it during the next few days after I buy some soil.

As before, as snagplus was saying:
TO ENLARGE THESE PICS, MOUSE OVER, RIGHT CLICK, OPEN IN NEW TAB OR WINDOW

JustPeachy

Registered:
Posts: 304

Greenfig, Thanks for your hard work with this experiment! Your results were quite surprising and I learned a lot too! :D

Maro2Bear

Registered:
Posts: 732

GreenFig, Keep the data coming! Really good comparative information for one and all. Tks

ascpete

Registered:
Posts: 1,942

Greenfig,
Thanks for the experiment and the updated data.
One benefit of the black pots on concrete that may not be evident...
The tree is automatically pruned by the heat, the root growth is decreased, decreasing the vegetative growth. This helps keeps the trees smaller for those who are growing in containers ; )

DallasFigs

Registered:
Posts: 990

If your still doing more tests, I'd like to see the black nursery pot on grass but shielded with reflective material (aluminum, or white paint, etc).  Thanks for the great info!

7deuce

Registered:
Posts: 566

Nice experiment! It was very educational.

susieqz

Registered:
Posts: 971

i luv this data. to start with, i'm burying my pots 1/2 way down.

many thanks green.

greg88

Registered:
Posts: 800

Good stuff.. did I miss where you published soil vs sand?

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Greg,

No, you didn't miss anything yet. I didn't want to just post short one-sentence updates. 
What new (unpublished) I have now is the soil temps in the same pots as the sand above +
the temps in 3 plastic black nursery pots covered by different things.

My thoughts were to test what people use most and what is easily available to buy. So, I got a white plastic pot, a white outside - black inside plastic growers bag, and foil.

Please see the temps for the soil in the 3 diff pots compared to the sand tamp attached.
It seems that as soon as you keep your pots watered, the light sand medium is as warm as the darker soil.

Energy loss thought the evaporation takes care of the heat added by the sun?

Tonight I should have the results for 3 black plastic covered by a white grower's bag and inserted in a white plastic pot.
Please see the photos attached.

Next: comparing the black nursery with a white grower's bag with a white plastic pot (what is used as a cover now).

Thanks for your interest!!


cis4elk

Registered:
Posts: 1,719

I'm confused, do you mean that the black plastic pot wins the prize of crappiest root environment? Because it is the farthest from ground soil growing conditions always, based off of these results.
By the way, great work once again. Very useful information.

I wonder also how much the last test would vary with all three pots the same inside and out, except

one directly on grass
a small sheet of weed block material under one
a small sheet of plastic under one
a paver stone or piece flagstone or similar under one
and ground control as always
(I realize this would require one more probe than you have so it would require more than one run, or just using the old info from the pot directly on grass loam)

Reason being, if a person wants to not have the roots grow into the ground(some don't) then what is the best option for a root block that allows heat to be moderated by the earth.

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

[QUOTE=cis4elk]I'm confused, do you mean that the black plastic pot wins the prize of crappiest root environment? Because it is the farthest from ground soil growing conditions always, based off of these results.
By the way, great work once again. Very useful information.

I wonder also how much the last test would vary with all three pots the same inside and out, except

one directly on grass
a small sheet of weed block material under one
a small sheet of plastic under one
a paver stone or piece flagstone or similar under one
and ground control as always
(I realize this would require one more probe than you have so it would require more than one run, or just using the old info from the pot directly on grass loam)

Reason being, if a person wants to not have the roots grow into the ground(some don't) then what is the best option for a root block that allows heat to be moderated by the earth.[/QUOTE]

Calvin,
You got it right! The cheapest and the most widely available pot is the worst one!

I think because it is
1) black, and 2) does not allow the water evaporation which cools it down greatly.

As I mentioned previously, the results and conclusions are the most relevant for the hot climates, where the sun is brutal. I am sure somewhere further North the value of having the plants in the black plastic is greater.

Thanks for the ideas. I will try to test as much I can.

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Here are the measuring results in the 3 black 2 gal nursery pots filled with dark potting soil and located on the loan grass..
1 is exposed fully
1 is covered by a white plastic grower's bag
1 is inserted in a white bucket

The protection of the plastic pots helps a little but they still are not as good as the terra-cotta or fabric but became much better!


For tomorrow I should have 1 exposed, 1 covered by foil, 1 covered by a brown paper bag.

Thanks for looking!

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Hi again,

I realize that you already probably have the data fatigue but I would like to finish posting the results of the measurements just in case they will be useful.
Only one more test left after this.

Today are the results of the temps in the 3 black 2 gal nursery pots in the following setting:
1. covered by a paper bag
2. bare black pot
3. wrapped in a foil 

+ the inground soil temp.

All 3 pots are filled with some dark potting soil that I use for figs. The soil was moist as if the figs grow there.

A big surprise: the paper bag cover is BETTER than the foil! By a little but still better.
The bare black pot suck big time, as expected.

Tomorrow: white growers bag, bare, white square plastic pot: like in the Sep03 photo but without the place pot inside.

Thanks for watching!

TO ENLARGE THE PIC, MOUSE OVER, RIGHT CLICK, OPEN IN NEW TAB OR WINDOW


greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

So, here is my last test.

You will find the results of the temp measurements in the 2 gal
1) white plastic grower's bag
2) white square plastic pot
3) black nursery pot
4) inground soil 

As you can see from the green line displaying the temp in the ground, today was as hot as yesterday, the black pot temps are also the same.

Surprisingly, the white grower's bag is not as good as the black covered in foil or a paper bag. This is good news since we have a lot of those black pots!
In the hot climate covering them with almost anything helps a lot and may prevent roots from cooking.

Happy figging, everyone! I hope the test results help at least one person :)
If you have any questions, please ask.

TO ENLARGE THE PIC, MOUSE OVER, RIGHT CLICK, OPEN IN NEW TAB OR WINDOW

javajunkie

Registered:
Posts: 1,523

WOW Igor,
I've kept up with your results and I am a little scared for my figs in black plastic pots. Looks like I'm going to be busy covering them today. Your analysis of temps is invalueable and I thank you.

jake

Registered:
Posts: 313

What would be the results if tests were done on actual growing plants. I took a look at mine yesterday and found most pots to be in the shade throughout most of the day. The shade from their own foilage or the plants adjacent to them. True, before they become large enough they are exposed to direct sun but seem to grow quite nicely under the sun of Northwest Florida.

Jake

ascpete

Registered:
Posts: 1,942

Jake,
I posted a link earlier in this Topic  to a Kansas State Thesis that documents growing plants in different colored pots and the resulting differences in root mass and  above ground mass. attached is a picture of one of the included diagrams.

greg88

Registered:
Posts: 800

great info,  confirms most of what I had suspected. I have painted my black pots white with a noticable difference in soil temp as measured by my fingers  ;o)

jake

Registered:
Posts: 313

[QUOTE=ascpete]Jake,
I posted a link earlier in this Topic  to a Kansas State Thesis that documents growing plants in different colored pots and the resulting differences in root mass and  above ground mass. attached is a picture of one of the included diagrams.[/QUOTE]

I took a look at your previous post. I am with most, plants in pots is not the best way to go,but a reality. As far as vegtables, I have grown them in containers for years. When I look at a 6-7 foot tomato plant loaded with tomatoes it's hard to convince myself I should not have it in a black palstic pot. Granted moisture really becomes important,usually requiring two watering a day. Locally there is a large wholesale nursery, with what appears to be hundred's of thousands if not millions of black plastic pots each with it's own species of plant. Some large,some small. The same ones you buy at the large retail outlets. It would be a task to convince them they need to cover or paint each individual pot.

Jake

ascpete

Registered:
Posts: 1,942

Jake,
There is no denying that the plants will grow, The argument is being made to grow them in white or light colored containers. There has been much documented about the increase in plant size and root mass when soil temperatures are moderated, its accepted in the nursery industry, one national wholesale nursery has already changed their pots to white exteriors, cost is usually the limiting factor (black pots are cheaper). And as the document stated there was an increase in root mass and top growth with lowered soil temperatures, it was an over 200% increase for both.

BTW, try a side by side comparison next season, you will absolutely see the difference.

elin

Registered:
Posts: 1,272

maybe nurseries preffer to keep plants size down?

Bosco

Registered:
Posts: 211

My thanks greenfig, this has been very educational.  Plus, a timely subject..!  

We’ve had somewhat of an unusual hot spell here and I been wondering if it was affecting my babies.  They are in direct sun and of course, I had just moved them up to 3 gal plastic before this heat wave hit……urgh.  I have been going a little heavy on water to keep cool, think now maybe I’ll pile some loose straw where direct sun hits for protection.   Think too, I’ll put a soil thermometer on my list.  Thanks again for sharing.

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

Thank you all for your input!
I am glad that you find the results interesting/valuable.

Pete, the Kansas State results can be considered now a subset of ours since we tested more pot combinations :)
it is nice they almost match what we have also found.

On a serious note, I have learned a few things about the black pot gardening.
I was especially surprised by the amount of cooling done via the water evaporation.

Some noticeable improvements can be done through:

1. placing a pot in a shade or shielding the pot with paper, wood, fabric, etc.
2. location, location, location... The cement floor is bad, the grass loan is better, half burying is best.
3. choosing a non-plastic pot (terra-cotta, fabric)
4. regular watering, the water evaporation is a huge energy draw for the soil
5. pot color, the light is better

But again, you have to adjust the results to your climate needs. In the south you want to keep the pots cool, in the north you might want to keep them on the sun since it is not as hot.

ascpete

Registered:
Posts: 1,942

Greenfig,
Thanks again for formulating your experiments and posting the results.

The conclusion for potted figs may be that you can use the Sun to "Solar Prune" the fig trees. The heat automatically prunes the roots at the perimeter of the pots, which also reduces the top growth. This actually reinforces Belleclaires method of growing potted figs : )

DaveL

Registered:
Posts: 247

Getting into that time of the summer again and I thought I would revive an old post by greenfig. Trying a couple alternatives using the auto sun reflective shields and bungees. The shields are only $1 at the dollar stores and the same for the bungees. Was able to wrap the pots, however only wrapped the west facing side of the Sips to deal with the mid day heat.

elin

Registered:
Posts: 1,272

I believe that loamy soil in pots heats like a soup bowl and thus the plants suffered. the plants stayed hot even through the night and couldnt cool down.

The only plants which did well even in full sun were in good aerated potting mix.

nycfig

Registered:
Posts: 886

I remember after reading this thread and several other similar ones I ran out and bought Reflectix from HD.

c1e57298-d4b9-4510-b83d-9ce0b0129775_1000.jpg 

Made little 'space jackets' for cuttings in the 1 gal. black nursery pots.  I no longer use those pots but it did work well at the time.  

 

goodeats4me

Registered:
Posts: 25

I have about half a house worth of plywood cut into squares of various sizes that shield my pots. I use one large one as the main blocker and a smaller one to help out if I don't move them quickly enough as the sun moves. It doesn't look great but works well. It was 115F a few days ago and my figs looked great all day. I was getting rid of a couple of Janice cuttings that were not doing well compared to the others the soil was very hot and the root growth was very poor. Does anyone have experience with Janice in scorching heat.

elin

Registered:
Posts: 1,272

Bumping this important topic again, This year i will use single use alluminium pans to cover one side of my pots as the sides abut other pots. Does anyone have any experience using them?? They should be good for several seasons?? They are with much thicker than foil. Each one costs 0.15 cents.

NoelG_123

Registered:
Posts: 180

My kids bought me a laser measuring gun. Was not expensive and works pretty good. I went out to the green house on Christmas day and checked temps on surfaces (it only measures surface temps) Most of the soils temps. were in the mid- 70's which I think is good. I've included a link.   https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00DMI632G/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o01_s01?ie=UTF8&psc=1

elin

Registered:
Posts: 1,272

Noel thanks, your lucky with 72..
Here I get 107f in black pots. Maybe ill start cooking steaks on these black pots :)

greenfig

Registered:
Posts: 3,182

I used the aluminum to cover the pots, worked well. I believe the aluminum pans would work in a similar way. Good luck with this , please let us know on the results