Encanto Farms Nursery > Categories > Perter's Honey, is it the same with the fig known as Kadota?

Author Comment
kenny

Registered:
Posts: 46

Hi all, I am looking to find Perter's honey live plant then someone on told me it maybe the same variety as the other fig known as Kadota. Somebody please enlighten me.

Many thanks in advance
Kenny

DallasFigs

Registered:
Posts: 990

Nope. they are not the same. 

kenny

Registered:
Posts: 46

Glad I asked, Thank you James. Do you know of anybody who has this Peter's honey plant I can buy from?

Thanks again :-)

figgary

Registered:
Posts: 833

Hi Kenny. I got mine from Dave Wilson Nursery in California, through my local nursery. Check their site. Gary in CA

kenny

Registered:
Posts: 46

Thanks for the info Gary :-) I did looked up Dave Wilson and there's no nursery that carries their figs :-( I guess I'd keep watching ebay :-)

dfoster25

Registered:
Posts: 723

I got mine from Edible Landscaping.

javajunkie

Registered:
Posts: 1,523

A seller on ebay that goes by Apache has cuttings for sale. I have bought cuttings from them before and they were great.

Aaron4USA

Registered:
Posts: 2,969

@Kenny, until the final list of Synonyms is ready for every one to use, you can click on the thread bellow and see which Variety has what Synonym...
You can find Kadota with it's Synonyms and Peter's Honey..if it has one.
Good luck ;)

Edit: Lemon, Dokkar, LSU Everbearing, White Texas Everbearing, Kadota and Trojano (non verified source)

kenny

Registered:
Posts: 46

Thank you all for your help and info! So glad to be here' :-)

ako1974

Registered:
Posts: 299

I was confused by this as well. Edible Landscaping shows on their website that they are the same:

http://ediblelandscaping.com/buyPlants.php

In zone 7, Kadota is an open bush, ripening most of its figs on last years growth. The fruits are yellow, medium to large size and delicious, ripening best with full sun and hot temperatures. Also known as Peter's Honey fig.

armando93223

Registered:
Posts: 1,164

I tasted a 3 foot tall Kadota and a Peter's Honey at a local history, the Kadota was sweeter. Sometimes you don't want them to sweet.

game_dog

Registered:
Posts: 12

Both are from Sicily, and excellent.  Not the same fig however.

Kadota (Dottato) --> http://www.scordo.com/2011/08/the-figs-of-calabria.html

A good description for both can be found here -->  http://www.adrianosfigtrees.com/varieties.html

Like anything else, make sure you purchase from a reliable source. 

Plenty of reputable members on this site sell cuttings/trees.

snaglpus

Registered:
Posts: 4,072

Alan----yes.

DallasFigs

Registered:
Posts: 990

[QUOTE=javajunkie]A seller on ebay that goes by Apache has cuttings for sale. I have bought cuttings from them before and they were great.[/QUOTE]

I second that. I got some Peter's Honey cuttings from him last year. Cut most off then in half and ended up with 9 trees. (All survived me). Gave them all away but one, which I have in a big 20gal tub now.

mgginva

Registered:
Posts: 1,856

There is currently a seller on Ebay by the name of familyelbow selling "new' Kadotas. All their info was swiped from Edible Landscaping. They are claiming their fig is the same as Peter's Honey (because that's what EL is saying). I have Dottato (Kadota) and Peter's Honey and they are certainly not the same fig.

game_dog

Registered:
Posts: 12

I personally purchased my Peter's Honey from 'Bay Flora' (along with a White Genoa) and am VERY pleased with both.

kenny

Registered:
Posts: 46

I got the Peter's Honey from the ebay seller by the name Apache, the listing was for 4 cuttings but I received 5, very nice to have a bonus when you didn't expecting any extra. I have them in the perlite/compost mix and hoping they will root. I'm just looking for the plants to make sure I have a live plant back up as I am not experienced with rooting.

So glad I found this forum, full of info and nice ppeps.

Thank you all for all you share :-)

Grasa

Registered:
Posts: 1,819

Kenny, I am happy to send you more of those cuttings if you have problem rooting yours. I do not sell them, I do ask for the postage. I was given 2 trees, one is full of brebas!.

kenny

Registered:
Posts: 46

Grasa, Thank you so much! I sent you PM.

ascpete

Registered:
Posts: 1,942

Kenny,
Peter's Honey and Kadota are two different figs. They may be related, but have different origins.
Kadota is a sport (mutation) of Dotatto and is well documented.
[QUOTE]http://figs4fun.com/Links/FigLink051.pdf (The Kadota Fig by W. Sam Clark),
Discovery
The honor and credit for the discovery of the remarkable fig now known as the Kadota belongs exclusively to that wise old horticulturist, the late Stephen H. Taft, of Sawtelle, a member of the Centenary Club of Southern California. When nearing the brave old age of five score years he crossed over the funset sea, leaving behind him a horticultural triumph whose magnitude and
value were but faintly appreciated even by himself. As the planted acres of this fig are leaping from hundreds into thousands, and demand outstrips all possible production even now, only then does the true worth of this fig appear and the magnitude of the discovery become apparent to those interested in this branch of horticulture. The original tree of this variety, then a stranger, discovered and named by Mr. Taft and afterward distributed, first appeared in an orchard grown by Mr. Cyrus Way of Whittier, from cuttings furnished by Mr. Iheo. Hockett, from his orchard of Dottaios, which in turn was an orchard grown from cuttings imported from Europe in 1887, by Mr. R. Thompson of Orange County, California. In the orchard grown by Mr. Way was one only tree of most remarkable vigor, growth, and early production, and in every way superior to the balance of the orchard surrounding it. The discriminating judgment of Mr. Taft immediately recognized in this stranger the very qualities and virtues so long sought by all progressive fig growers the world over. Whether it be an off-shoot, a sport, or a freak of nature, matters but little to us now, and its remarkable achievements in the few short years of its existence has astounded the fig growers of central California, and it now stands at the very head of all figs of its class, and has indeed created a branch of the fig industry all its own.[/QUOTE]
Peter's Honey, 
[QUOTE]http://figs4fun.com/Varieties.html '
Native to Sicily it was brought to the northwest where it is popular by Peter Danna of Portland.[/QUOTE]

kenny

Registered:
Posts: 46

Thank you for the information Pete, it is amazing how much information comes thru once one ask - and this is only around two varieties!

Posturedoc

Registered:
Posts: 159

This topic comes up periodically. Aaron's link to the F4F fig database suggests Kadota as a synonym for Peter's Honey and I've read on other threads where collectors claim their PH, Kadota and White Texas Everbearing are the same fig. In my collection, Kadota is definitely a different fig, but PH, purchased from Burnt Ridge Nursery, and WTE, from Davis, are the same.

pino

Registered:
Posts: 2,117

game_dog,
dottato is not from Sicily check your link; 
Kadota aka (sport of) Dottato --> http://www.scordo.com/2011/08/the-figs-of-calabria.html

Calabria is not Sicily. Dottato is from Calabria (province of Crotone to be more precise). 

DesertDance

Registered:
Posts: 4,518

I think I would take Kadota over Peter's Honey any day.  I bet Italian honey is only good on his Vespa!
Suzi

GreenFin

Registered:
Posts: 684

[QUOTE=ascpete]Kenny,
Peter's Honey and Kadota are two different figs. They may be related, but have different origins.
Kadota is a sport (mutation) of Dotatto and is well documented.
[QUOTE]http://figs4fun.com/Links/FigLink051.pdf (The Kadota Fig by W. Sam Clark),
Discovery
The honor and credit for the discovery of the remarkable fig now known as the Kadota belongs exclusively to that wise old horticulturist, the late Stephen H. Taft, of Sawtelle, a member of the Centenary Club of Southern California. When nearing the brave old age of five score years he crossed over the funset sea, leaving behind him a horticultural triumph whose magnitude and
value were but faintly appreciated even by himself. As the planted acres of this fig are leaping from hundreds into thousands, and demand outstrips all possible production even now, only then does the true worth of this fig appear and the magnitude of the discovery become apparent to those interested in this branch of horticulture. The original tree of this variety, then a stranger, discovered and named by Mr. Taft and afterward distributed, first appeared in an orchard grown by Mr. Cyrus Way of Whittier, from cuttings furnished by Mr. Iheo. Hockett, from his orchard of Dottaios, which in turn was an orchard grown from cuttings imported from Europe in 1887, by Mr. R. Thompson of Orange County, California. In the orchard grown by Mr. Way was one only tree of most remarkable vigor, growth, and early production, and in every way superior to the balance of the orchard surrounding it. The discriminating judgment of Mr. Taft immediately recognized in this stranger the very qualities and virtues so long sought by all progressive fig growers the world over. Whether it be an off-shoot, a sport, or a freak of nature, matters but little to us now, and its remarkable achievements in the few short years of its existence has astounded the fig growers of central California, and it now stands at the very head of all figs of its class, and has indeed created a branch of the fig industry all its own.[/QUOTE][/QUOTE]
Thanks for sharing this.  I've passed on getting Kadota before because I've got Dottato and I thought that they were supposed to be not just very similar, but of equal repute; I hadn't realized that Kadota was supposed to be some sort of significant improvement over the Dottato.  Now I think I want to add Kadota to my cuttings wishlist.

sarahkt

Registered:
Posts: 100

Anyone buy a Peter's Honey from Raintree, and compare with a Kadota? I ordered a PH from Raintree earlier this year, no fruit yet. I'm curious because there's been multiple threads on some people (including sellers) confusing PH with Kadota, and nurseries selling them interchangeably. I was wondering you find them to be entirely separate types, or if you think they're similar too. I haven't liked Kadotas from the store, and while I know there's a HUGE difference between unripe store ones and ones picked ripe, I'm hoping my PH is not a Kadota. 

Did you happen to buy your PH from Raintree, or if not, do you know if others who have bought from Raintree are satisfied that their tree is a PH and not a Kadota? My first tree I bought from them turned out to be a Reverse/unknown instead of a Panache, so there's a precedence for mixups there, at least in my experience. Mixups do happen, and I've been pleased with my other orders from there, but still want to clarify on this point. 

Figgysid1

Registered:
Posts: 388

Here is a picture of my kadota leaf and peter's honey leaf.  If I lose a tag I cannot tell the difference until they fruit.  My peter's honey figs will always make a bunch of twin figs(2 figs on one node).  My kadota fig does not make twins so that is one easy way to tell. 

Kadota

Scan0025.jpg 
Peter's honey
Scan0026.jpg

scott_ga

Registered:
Posts: 302

Peter's_Honey_Breba_and_main_6-22-08.jpg Here Peter's Honey brebas are the best--main crop a little insipid for my taste

sarahkt

Registered:
Posts: 100

I had some Kadota cuttings forgotten in the fridge, just rooted them today. Will compare them to my PH when they fruit.